If you could create your custom Halloween candy bag of 5...

[Anonymous]

Kit Kat
Twix
Sour patch kids
Butterfinger
Milky Way

Bonus points if they could all be in dark chocolate form.

[Anonymous]

JUSTIN'S Peanut Butter Cups (certified organic).

Outside of them, there really isn't one piece of popular Halloween candy that I'd not regret eating afterwords. Corn syrup and palm oil, yummy!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I prefer Bit-o-Honey over MaryJanes. They have to make candy for us Goldenberg’s Peanut Chews folk!

Yum. I like both. But I prefer the softish center of the Mary Jane's. I think we are the minority though!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:The pumpkin shaped Reeces cups
mini Twizzler pull n peel
swedish fish
Milky way simply caramel
Mounds

Yes!! As an adult, I love good quality dark chocolate and mostly can't stand the junky candy. Tastes fake and gross. EXCEPT these. The Reece's holiday shaped things (pumpkin, the xmas tree, easter egg, heart) are pure perfection. But you have to get the regular size. The mini version isn't as good and has a different chocolate/PB ratio.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I think my worst five would be:

Bit o honey
Laffy taffy
Pixie straws
Pay day
The generic no-name chocolate that tastes like dust (I always eat that and then am always mad at myself)

I also hate the generic dust tasting chocolates (they actually taste like waxy dust, that was a good descriptor). Otherwise, we’d make great trade partners as I love those other candies .

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I think my worst five would be:

Bit o honey
Laffy taffy
Pixie straws
Pay day
The generic no-name chocolate that tastes like dust (I always eat that and then am always mad at myself)

I can’t believe someone upthread put MaryJanes on their Top 5 list. Cheapest, lamest Halloween candy ever. On the rare occasion the kids still get them, we roll our eyes and assume the giver was 95 years old.

Are you the Almond Joy on a roadtrip poster? Why are you here?

What? No. I love good Halloween candy. Everyone knows Mary Janes are nasty.

[Anonymous]

As a kid:
Lick-a-Stick
Pop Rocks
Candy Cigarettes
Peppermint Patties or Junior Mints
Charleston Chew (frozen)
Candy necklace

Now:
Almond Joy
Snickers
Reese’s pieces
Reese’s cups
Mr. Goodbar
Would still be nostalgic for the 1st list though

[Anonymous]

Skittles
Take 5
Heath
KitKat
York peppermint patties

[Anonymous]

Reese's
Twix
Junior Mints
Peanut M&Ms
Almond Joy

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:JUSTIN'S Peanut Butter Cups (certified organic).

Outside of them, there really isn't one piece of popular Halloween candy that I'd not regret eating afterwords. Corn syrup and palm oil, yummy!

Get your hands on some Chocolove salted peanut butter. It is what Reese's was meant to be.

[Anonymous]

Does this combination have to be possible? I want to include Sno Caps, but they only seem to come in theater boxes.

Anyway.

Mounds
Butterfinger
Peanut butter M&Ms
SNO CAPS, dammit
Junior Mints

[Anonymous]

Kitkit
Twix
3 muscateers
peppermint patties
Reeses

[Anonymous]

Mounds
Skor
Reese's peanut butter cups
Twizzlers
Perugina dark chocolate with lemon

[Anonymous]

Reese’s cups
Snickers
Twizzlers
Krackle
Gummy bears

[Anonymous]

Reese’s peanut butter cups
Snickers
Peanut m&ms (not peanut butter m&ms, the peanut ones)
Butterfingers
Toss up between Almond joy or mounds for the 5th one

I would not take any other candy from my kids’ loot. Can’t stand any fruity or gummy candy, suckers, or any other of the usual Halloween chocolates than those i listed above. The only other thing I might sneak from their stash would be the salty “treats” people sometimes pass out like chips or cheese balls or goldfish.