If you could create your custom Halloween candy bag of 5...

[Anonymous]

kit kat
reeces
milky way
three muskateers
heath bar

[Anonymous]

Dark chocolate from my favorite Paris chocolaterie.
And candied fruit.

Good thing I went recently and stocked up. I'm not sharing, sorry.

[Anonymous]

Nerds
Nestle Crunch
Snickers
Almond Joy
Sour Patch kids

[Anonymous]

Heath bars
Werther’s caramels
Jolly ranchers (love the classic and all variations other than the chewy ones—sour surge is my current fave)
Toxic waste hard candies
Can’t decide among Spree, Skittles, Zotz, and Charms blow pops.

I’d also be completely fine with 5 different types of Jolly Ranchers.

[Anonymous]

Heath bars
Peanut M&Ms
Kit Kat
Butterfinger
100 Grand

Backup: Reeses or Yellow laffy taffy

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:My perfect old lady bag would include:
Junior Mints
Necco Wafers
Candy Corns
Skor
100 Grand

You are my candy soulmate.

[Anonymous]

Reese's pumpkins
York peppermint patties
Snickers
Candy corn packets but they have to be fresh
Peanut M&Ms

Also since this is imaginary, the mint from the peppermint patties has to magically not transfer to any of the other candy

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I know there are different brands, but there's always something in one of the mixed bags that I throw out (and be honest, some of the candy is for ourselves). Why isn't there an all-peanut bag? Why does the nut-variety bag have to include one thing with almonds?!

If you could create your custom Halloween candy bag of 5 things, what would you make?

If the universe were just, then the Halloween bags would only contain Almond Joy and chocolate covered almonds.

[Anonymous]

Mounds
Snickers
Kit-Kat
Twix
Peanut M&Ms

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Reese’s cups
Milky Way
Mounds
Kit Kat
Twix

I think I buy this all in one bag.

[Anonymous]

Reese's peanut butter cups
Snickers
Twix
Three Musketeers
Toss up between Skittles/Starbursts/Sour Patch Kids

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I know there are different brands, but there's always something in one of the mixed bags that I throw out (and be honest, some of the candy is for ourselves). Why isn't there an all-peanut bag? Why does the nut-variety bag have to include one thing with almonds?!

If you could create your custom Halloween candy bag of 5 things, what would you make?

If the universe were just, then the Halloween bags would only contain Almond Joy and chocolate covered almonds.

YUCK. Do you also like black jellybeans?!?

[Anonymous]

Twix, butterfingers, baby ruth, snickers, peanut M&Ms

Butterfingers are only enjoyable fun-sized

[Anonymous]

Mine would be caramel themed with NO NUTS:

Twix
Rollo
Milky Way
100 Grand
Milky Way Midnight

[Anonymous]

Mr. Goodbar
Butterfinger
Reese's Dark Miniatures
MaryJanes
Tootsie Roll vanilla midgies