Forum Index
»
DC Public and Public Charter Schools
How many kids apply each year to Walls? 2,000? Is there any private school that gets even half as many applicants? (And the private school applicant pools are surely shallower than they appear because so many kids apply to multiple privates). Privates not only have a much smaller group of kids to pick from, but they also have to put a thumb (or two) on the scale for those whose parents can pay full freight. The statistics don't work, sweetie. |
Walls has a large applicant pool not because the school has the smartest kids but because so many families in the city are desperate for a decent high school. You are delusional if you think the 9th grade admits to Walls are smarter than the 9th grade admits to Sidwell, GDS, etc… Sorry but you are just showing your ignorance of the private school admissions when it comes to high school. And no, my kid does not go to private school. |
Sorry but you are just showing your ignore of basic statistics. |
Ah yes, just because Walls has lots of applicants doesn’t represent the fact that there are no other viable options for many families in the city but rather that they have the smartest group of kids in this town. Yet 1/3rd of them can’t even do grade level math. LOL! |
|
Walls doesn't have the smartest students. It has bright students, but not necessarily the smartest.
If they wanted the smartest students, they would use a test to determine admissions. Instead, they use 10-minute interviews conducted by unqualified, untrained interviewers to select on some fuzzy something-or-nother about "demanding one's education." Private schools use test scores, 30+ minute interviews, multiple student-written essays, multiple parent-written essays, and shadow days -- in addition to transcripts and recommendations. Who do you think is better at picking the best students? |
Are you new to DC? This isn't a reflection of the standards at Walls. it's a reflection of the politics of Washington D.C. The last thing people want here is an elite publicly funded high school that is mostly Asian and White. Have you not ever noticed that we have zero schools that look like Bronx Sci or Stuy or TJ or Boston Latin? If the admissions standards seem vague, it's to allow the school to try to get the demographic mix that is required. |
That is funny because I know so many mediocre white kids who game the system by taking the easiest classes at mediocre dcps schools knowing their kids would drown at Basis or even Latin. Walls is easy and a great fit for an average student who would struggle at a really good school. |
You and PP are both right. |
I think TJ has actually solved for this by indicating they will accept the top students from each area of the county that is eligible for TJ. They eliminated their entrance test as well. As long as the school itself doesn't change in the content, teaching quality, etc., I have zero problem if every area that pays taxes to support a school gets an allocation of kids that get to attend. |
I don't know the exact percentage, but a significant number of kids who attend Sidwell, GDS, Maret as examples have been there since K. They obviously, didn't have to do any of the things mentioned above. |
Yeah, literally no one does this, and, even if they did, schools employ these people called "admissions officers" whose entire jobs are comparing the records of kids from different schools and backgrounds. |
And of the tens and tens of kids who apply for ninth grade, I'm sure they only accept the very best of those who don't require too much financial aid. |
They do all those things, except for the student-written essays! There is a standardized test kids take for private preschool and kindergarten, but not for Walls. |
Well, there aren't transcripts and recommendations either. |
The idea of giving standardized tests to four year olds seems ridiculous, unless they're just using it to screen out kids with learning disabilities, in which case it's despicable. |