Forum Index
»
Travel Discussion
m I’m sure those polls were take in Paris and other urban areas. The vast majority of the rural areas where the actual French people live are completely different. |
I think I’ve told this story here before, but during Trump’s first term we were checking out of our hotel in Italy, and the elderly man working the front desk said in very broken English (still way better than my very bad Italian) “God Bless your President Trump.” As somebody who is very anti-Trump, all I could do is smile. To us it was a very strange and surprising interaction, and another reason why I never talk politics. |
|
Absolutely ashamed of Trump and the whole government nowl
I don't plan to travel abroad. |
Typical DCUM poster. That's your anecdote and you're sticking to it. The "vast majority" of "actual French people" are not rural. More than 80 percent of the French population lives in cities. |
You don't understand-- they don't count as "actual French people", just Americans who live in cities like NY, Chicago and LA aren't "real Americans"
|
Urban zones in France are defined in such a way people could live somewhere Americans would perceive as a village and be considered as part of an urban zone, so this poster is not wrong though you are also correct in terms of statistics. The 80% aren't all in huge cities. For instance I have family in a tiny 3k town, but it's technically counted as "urban" because it's in the sphere of a larger city and geographically close enough to it. You have to go far out in the mountains to not be considered urban. |
Many of them are recent immigrants, however, and not French citizens. |
This. Thank you. |
Nah, many of us can easily blend in with Europeans. And when our European family members visit us here in the US, they also blend in. I'm quite sure no one realizes they're foreign by the looks of them. When they open their mouths to speak, yes, the foreign accent is obvious, but the appearance indistinguishable. |
I never said 80 percent live in "huge cities." You don't have to live in "huge cities" anywhere in the world to be considered urban. Green Bay, Wisconsin is "urban." There are numerous articles on the web about the decline in population in rural France, how young folks are abandoning rural areas for the cities, and how the large majority of rural French residents are older. That's why you're seeing rural areas being far more likely to have Trump supporters. But that's not typical France. Twenty percent of the population lives in greater Paris alone. |
This, what? |
Green Bay, WI is a small city though. As PP explained to you, places in France with as little as 3,000 people are considered urban zones. In any event, I imagine the polls were taken largely in the biggest few French cities, like Paris, Marseille, Lille, Lyon and Toulouse. Those cities also have huge student populations, including international students, which will skew the statistics considerably. Trust me, plenty of middle aged, older French people in what we would consider rural areas are very pro Trump. Incredibly so. I live here. |
Thirteen percent of French residents are foreign born. Meaning that 87 percent are not. So I guess it depends on your definition of "many." This is such a ridiculous discussion. You're just not going to budge. Facts don't matter, polls don't matter, nothing matters to you but your "feelings" and your anecdotes. It's impossible to have a real conversation on this website. Trump is not popular in the US, and he's less popular in France than he is here. That's the bottom line. |
So the F what. The polls take these things into account. They're not student polls, they are representative polls. No one is denying that Trump has some support in France, especially among older residents worried about immigration. That's not surprising because it's the same as here. But that does NOT mean the man is popular in France. You're like talking to a brick wall. |
| This is honestly a narcissistic take. Anyone reasonable knows a random tourist is not their government. That is true about Americans, Israelis, Russians, Iranians and anyone else. I’ve traveled throughout Europe, some people poke fun of Trump, some tell me they like him, no one has ever blamed me for anything because that would make no sense. |