This. My parents had biweekly cleaners for years but the clutter made it hard to do anything but vacuum the carpets and clean the sinks and toilets. I’m talking decades worth of dust and cat hair. It was awful. I gently suggested carpet cleaning a few times but they always said “oh we have cleaners.” Well lo and behold a few years after Mom passed, Dad started dating a woman who isn’t into clutter. (Love Mom but she was a borderline hoarder and so is Dad.) She moved in, they tossed years worth of stuff, deep cleaned the place - shampooed carpets, washed curtains, cleared surfaces to dust — and it’s actually habitable now. Short of that, unfortunately you’re unlikely to see a change … |
Your Dad used very gracious wording - and it's true, regardless of the recipients' housekeeping tendencies. I think this is the way to go! |
LOL |
| Hotel. |
|
"I mean, who wouldn’t want housecleaning on a regular schedule? I think it’s a fine gift and wouldn’t overthink it."
Oh hon, there are many who would not want this. A gift is about the person you're giving it to. This is about the giver - therefore not a gift. |
My parents wouldn't accept, do not want strangers in their house. |
I think this is a great idea if framed as a way to help OP's allergies. But yeah, some people wouldn't accept. My mom won't accept help with anything- either a cleaning service, or help from me (I haven't offered to regularly clean and I wouldn't, but I WOULD spend as many weekends as necessary helping with the decluttering in the basement and anywhere else. I have been declined for years even though she complains about the clutter almost every time we talk). |
| I wish people understood how miserable allergies can be. My oldest has terrible allergies to cats and dogs and even with medication feels terrible after a few hours at a house full of pet dander. Sleeping in a hotel would not be enough. I would just make it about you, this is a weird thing that you need not something wrong with them and ask if they would either be willing to have a crew come or to come to you for the next holiday. Expecting someone to be miserable so you can live in filth is not an acceptable option for me. (Note: this is actually not a problem with my ILs! My DD has a friend who has pets and they don’t clean and she can’t go there for more than a couple hours. We host instead). |
No he’s going to want to do it himself and then it’s going to be a huge struggle because he will want to keep too much. |
This. I hired painters who had just painted a neighbors house and they were so disgusted by how much they had to clean before they painted that they told me about it. My neighbor had a weekly cleaner but apparently they only ever swiffered floors and wiped off surfaces but didn't clean anything. They said every surface was grimy. A lot of cleaners don't really clean. I always check my tile kitchen floor after any cleaners I use. It gives me a clue how well they clean. |
| I think it could come across as rude. Maybe stay in a hotel? |
| I would not say anything about allergies. Just say “thank you for having us. To help with hosting and all the clean up we are paying for a one-time service. |
This is the best and most honest approach. |
| Just be frank and ask them how they can live in such a filthy place and what they're planning to make it normal. |
"But we want you to do it before we come." 🙄 |