I agree with this comment. My kid graduated from TJ last year with high stats but is attending an out of state university (with very high costs) because of rejection at UVA and wait list at VT. Many TJ kids go out of state for college. |
As much a myth as only Asian kids who are in TJ are the ones who enrolled in test prep programs. What is generally true is Asian parents allocate disproportionate amount of resources both in time and money than all other ethnic groups to their children. This should not be held against them. Instead it should be copied. It is also true URM communities lack the resources both in time and money that other communities have because of systematic discrimination and injustices. This should be remedied in a way that provides appropriate knowledge and resources to compete in equal footing and for lasting progress. The idea that we need to increase the number of URMs everywhere blindly is a short term eyewash and not feasible long term. These efforts won't create the long lasting impact that these communities need and deserve. |
+1 But most Asian students are busy with tutors themselves - for each and every class, then college prep, so they have little time to help others, unfortunately. |
Do you think your kid would have had a better shot at UVA/VT if they had stayed at their base school? |
Available data simply do not support this. 49 kids went to UVA from TJ. UVA yield is around 40% that means at least 120+ kids were accepted from TJ. UVA's overall acceptance rate is 21%. That means 583 kids from TJ applied must have applied to have that many acceptance which cannot not be the case because TJ class size is less than 450 kids. So the only way the math works if the acceptance rate is higher - between 35% - 40% ( almost double the UVA's overall acceptance rate). This means about 300 -350 kids applied to UVA which is very very close to actual application number UVA received from TJ in 2022. |
The simple reality is that UVA and VT practice yield protection. A couple of years ago, my kid got into UVA but not VT while also getting into a slew of OOS schools (one of which he chose to attend). We know of several that did not get into UVA and VT at that time and some of them had a better profile that my kid. So yield protection is real. If UVA/VT is your goal, go ED. IF waitlisted, make sure your LOCI clearly indicates your interest (send one even if they are not asking for one). |
Someone has to be in the bottom 25-30%, it’s called having a range of abilities. |
Quite a few TJs at Rice. They are often among the stars and do really well. |
My bet would be that the acceptance rate from TJ to UVA is significantly higher than the in-state average, the yield rate is lower than the in-state average, and the stats (standardized test) scores of the accepted and enrolled kids from TJ are considerably higher than the in-state average. I say this because the average Asian admitted to UVA has higher stats than other groups (and by a large margin over other minority groups), and TJ may well have the highest percentage of Asians of any public school in the state. The 49 kids attending TJ is up from 37 the prior year which is a bit of a reversal of a long term trend of fewer TJ kids going to UVA (105 enrolled at UVA from the class of 2012). VT had a high of 42 kids from TJ from the class of 2017, but the 7 from 2022 is probably an all-time low. The percentage of VT's class coming from TJ is significantly lower than it is for W&M and UVA. |
TJ standardized test score has always been higher than the county, state and national averages. Below link has the average score for class of 2021. https://tjhsst.fcps.edu/sites/default/files/media/inline-files/2022-23%20TJHSST%20Profile_0.pdf |
My point was that the scores for students accepted to and enrolled at UVA are likely higher than those of any other Virginia high school enrolling more than a certain number of students. That doesn't necessarily flow from TJ having the highest standardized test scores, which is clear from published data. It comes from TJ having a very high Asian population and data from FOIA requests showing Asians accepted to UVA have higher stats than other groups. https://www.ceousa.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/Preferences20in20Virginia20Higher20Education20-20September202019.pdf |
My DC loves TJ and so far, we are happy with the admission results. He applied to VT, UVA, UMD, Purdue, UIUC and Georgia tech. Got accepted by VT, Purdue and UMD. Deferred by UIUC and rejected by GT. Had he stayed in base school, he probably would have a shot at CMU or Cornell. But we, the parents, don't have the money to send him there. He loves VT. So we are satisfied with the results. 4-years of hardworking but overall it worth it. |
Adding, my DC is average or below average in TJ. Probably in the third quartile? Not sure.
SAT math 800 English 720 - English below 748 GPA 4.2x. Not sure about the average but feels like below average a bit |
At TJ, the scores are high in general, Asian or not. Our non-Asian child was accepted to UVA last year with an SAT score of 1580. |
That is certainly not below average but will likely be outside the top quartile. Are they a senior? If so, what were the college outcomes and what do they want to study? |