Anonymous wrote:
Ranking of all the new coaches;
1. D. Mitchell - DeMatha
2. H. Mitchell - Heights
3. D. Smith - Good Counsel
4. Jeff King - Gonzaga
Reasoning;
While many consider Boh Mitchell the better coach of the brothers (which he undoubtedly is), the heights is still at loss here because they had both Mitchell’s beforehand. D. Smith is an awesome recruiter and got some serious talent to come over to a weak St. Andrew’s, but on the field he is a weak coach. As far as Jeff King, it was a horrible hire. Instead of taking a more experienced and knowledgeable coach, Gonzaga took a former Assistant coach from their inner circle.
Is there any reason why you did not include Landon or even Paul VI on your list of new coaches? Landon arguably is the most recognizable name when it comes to lacrosse at the national level. The Heights and Good Counsel are really afterthoughts. Good Counsel will always be viewed as a football school - I don't ever forsee that changing.
As someone who knows Jeff King, I'm not sure how you are coming to that conclusion. He hasn't even coached a single game as a head coach yet and if he had not been hired, the entire current Gonzaga staff (all of their assistants) would have most likely resigned. What else should have Reyada done?
Dane Smith has done a nice job at St Andews, given its St Andrews, you can only go so far with a program in that league and a school that really is not widely known for any athletic success. It will be interesting to see what he does at Good Counsel.
I think Dave Mitchell runs a top-notch club program (sure like it better than Mad Lax) but will struggle as a head coach in a big-time lacrosse league. Coaching club, where games are running clock, still playing federation rules, penalties are running clocks, and scouting is non-factor, I don't see Dave taking the DM program to the promised land. He did a good job at the Heights but again the Heights is not widely known for their athletic programs and there really is no
pressure from the administration to win games.
PVI coach has never had a winning season as a rec coach, club coach or JV coach. He was a loyalty hire. While he’s an amazing person, very kind and generous coach, he was not the right hire.