Why racial segregation is unacceptable but socioeconomic segregation is ok in private schools

Anonymous
That way they won't be shocked when they have a six figure education debt for a job as a butler for the elite.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I am new to dc and I noticed the stark difference between the two types of segregation. Private schools are happy if they are racially diverse, but not so happy to be diverse in terms of socioeconomic groups. If find this attitude a bit schizophrenic. Do you think this is ok?


I think it’s pretty simple, racial segregation is viewed as a uniquely pernicious practice, both for contingent historical reasons and because basically everybody thinks that intentional racial discrimination is fundamentally unfair. A lack of socioeconomic diversity, however, is structurally inherent if your business model is “we’re going to charge a huge amount of money for something that is also available free of charge.” The great majority of people who see that as a viable option are going to be those for whom money is not a problem. I also think most of these schools do more than lip service in trying to find high talent kids from low SES communities—it adds value to the school community and they like to preen and take credit for such efforts, and they would, I think, do more of it if more low SES parents had any idea that, given a sufficiently talented kid, the schools can be flexible on money. I grew up low SES and it never crossed my mind that financial aid was even an option for high-end privates, and I assume there are lots of low SES parents of 140 IQ kids who have no idea they could apply to high end privates with reasonable prospects for major financial aid. Also travel logistics can be an issue.


Why shouldn't the lower IQ kids get a shot first? The smart ones will probably figure out how to get ahead while the lower IQ need all the help they can get?


Judging by your post, you need a school like that.


Oh, you were just looking for a free ride for your kid? Not really concerned about equity, I see.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I am new to dc and I noticed the stark difference between the two types of segregation. Private schools are happy if they are racially diverse, but not so happy to be diverse in terms of socioeconomic groups. If find this attitude a bit schizophrenic. Do you think this is ok?


I think it’s pretty simple, racial segregation is viewed as a uniquely pernicious practice, both for contingent historical reasons and because basically everybody thinks that intentional racial discrimination is fundamentally unfair. A lack of socioeconomic diversity, however, is structurally inherent if your business model is “we’re going to charge a huge amount of money for something that is also available free of charge.” The great majority of people who see that as a viable option are going to be those for whom money is not a problem. I also think most of these schools do more than lip service in trying to find high talent kids from low SES communities—it adds value to the school community and they like to preen and take credit for such efforts, and they would, I think, do more of it if more low SES parents had any idea that, given a sufficiently talented kid, the schools can be flexible on money. I grew up low SES and it never crossed my mind that financial aid was even an option for high-end privates, and I assume there are lots of low SES parents of 140 IQ kids who have no idea they could apply to high end privates with reasonable prospects for major financial aid. Also travel logistics can be an issue.


Why shouldn't the lower IQ kids get a shot first? The smart ones will probably figure out how to get ahead while the lower IQ need all the help they can get?


Judging by your post, you need a school like that.


Oh, you were just looking for a free ride for your kid? Not really concerned about equity, I see.


I pay full tuition no problem. Just don’t like the concept pf giving financial aid to a lot of upper middle class families that don’t need it, probably like you.
post reply Forum Index » Private & Independent Schools
Message Quick Reply
Go to: