+1 Yup. Totally obvious. |
Uh, Harvard just took in David Hogg who has stats lower than a school just a notch above CC. |
There’s no free lunch, PP, certainly not for HYPS. Water polo is highly competitive in CA, where the top schools do the bulk of their recruiting for this sport. The last few kids recruited from CA schools were standout stars. |
No way. the number of fencing spots open in any given year is miniscule. |
Agree. A kid on the east coast is going to have a hard time finding the level of competition needed to stand out with all of the west coast players. There just aren't that many teams. It could happen, but it would take extraordinary talent. |
Yep and the vast majority of them go to rated fencers. Hopefully your FB friend got hi daughter started in fencing young since it has become super competitive especially with Asians. Not being racist but the top 8 in most age groups and weapons at national events are Asian fencers. |
the vast majority? More like all of them and they're all extremely highly rated. Tons of fencers are rated. You probably have to be in the top 50 nationwide to even be considered for a spot. In any given year, in the Ivy League, there may be, at most, 8-10 open spots in any given weapon. The number of schools that have competitive fencing in the US is much lower than other sports. As far as the Asian comment goes, why does it matter what race or ethnicity is involved? It's not even remotely a true statement in any event. None of the top 8 U19 men's epee fencers are Asian. Maybe 2 of the top 8 foil fencers are Asian. 1 of the top 8 saber fencers for men. On the women's U19, maybe 4 out of 24 are Asian. If you're going to make a comment like that, do some basic research first. |
I completely lost respect for Harvard on this one. I admire Hogg's passion but he seems really immature and completely lacking in self-awareness. In my opinion he is not merely ineffective, but actually a detriment to the cause. |
Depends how you define "the cause." If it is to contribute to gun control and public safety, I agree with you. If it is to keep some anti-Trump narrative alive. Hogg is perfect for Harvard. |