Are you suggesting it's healthier to BF while snorting lines of Coke than while taking adderall? If not I'm not sure what cocaine has to do with any of this. |
| My understanding is that it's better to do this after the baby is 6 months (according to Jack Newman), because they can process the medication much better. I have adhd, normally take adderall, and think your plan to pump and dump is something that i'd feel comfortable with. A pp mentioned it's really about your baby's reaction. No harm in trying your plan once, seeing if there's any ill affect, and then adjusting. I'd also call Infant Risk, where you can get in touch with medical professionals who do have a lot of experience in pharmacology and BFing. I did not take adderall while breastfeeding my child and instead ate basically paleo and worked out for an hour or two each day while working full time. It was really tough mentally for me and you have to consider your own emotional well-being. |
Maybe neither one is good while BF? Sort of like saying that beer is a better choice than whiskey...reality is neither is good to consume while bfing. |
Thanks - how long did you suffer through/when did you wean? I still haven't picked up the prescription... still weighing options... |
I don't think anyone is arguing that adderall benefits breastfed babies. The very limited research just doesn't show it harms them and I was wondering about anecdotal experiences. |
PP whose psychiatrist did the research here - I hear you. No anecdotal experience, since we haven't tried it yet. Half of me feels like it doesn't hurt to try, the other half feels nervous exposing my baby to such a stimulant. Does anyone know, if I went the pump and dump route, how long should I wait for it to clear? I take regular, not extended release, and it usually feels out of my system after 3.5-4 hours. For PPs who say wean, I like to nurse, she's a great eater, and it's convenient, free, etc. Per my doctor, I'm not convinced it's medically necessary to wean, and if so, if it's worth losing the breastfeeding relationship. It's a hard decision! |
21 months - it felt okay while it was happening, but was a relief to go back on. |
But what's best for your baby? I can't imagine how anyone would think that drug-tainted breast milk is healthier than formula. |
|
PP whose psychiatrist did the research here - I hear you. No anecdotal experience, since we haven't tried it yet. Half of me feels like it doesn't hurt to try, the other half feels nervous exposing my baby to such a stimulant. Does anyone know, if I went the pump and dump route, how long should I wait for it to clear? I take regular, not extended release, and it usually feels out of my system after 3.5-4 hours. For PPs who say wean, I like to nurse, she's a great eater, and it's convenient, free, etc. Per my doctor, I'm not convinced it's medically necessary to wean, and if so, if it's worth losing the breastfeeding relationship. It's a hard decision! I know it's hard - I am different than PP, and I liked to nurse, my daughter was a good eater, the convenience was AMAZING, and I was sad to give up the breastfeeding, but it was what was best for my baby. Even if you can't prove that taking adderall and breastfeeding is harmful to your baby's brain and body, there's at least a chance it may be harmful, so it wasn't worth it to me to take that chance just so I could enjoy breastfeeding & take my adderall. So when it was time to go back on the meds, I dropped breastfeeding. I miss it, but then I remind myself that I'm not feeding my daughter amphetamines - in however small quantities. I guess you have to assess how much your are BF'ing for you, and how much you are doing it for your baby. Personally, I wasn't comfortable with the unknowns and potential for harm, especially since my own doctors didn't recommend it. It wasn't worth it to me. |
I know it's hard - I am different than PP, and I liked to nurse, my daughter was a good eater, the convenience was AMAZING, and I was sad to give up the breastfeeding, but it was what was best for my baby. Even if you can't prove that taking adderall and breastfeeding is harmful to your baby's brain and body, there's at least a chance it may be harmful, so it wasn't worth it to me to take that chance just so I could enjoy breastfeeding & take my adderall. So when it was time to go back on the meds, I dropped breastfeeding. I miss it, but then I remind myself that I'm not feeding my daughter amphetamines - in however small quantities. I guess you have to assess how much your are BF'ing for you, and how much you are doing it for your baby. Personally, I wasn't comfortable with the unknowns and potential for harm, especially since my own doctors didn't recommend it. It wasn't worth it to me. But this can apply to anything - including formula. For example, there are more studies proving that formula can have long term ill effects on a baby than there are proving that Adderall can. I'm not saying this means it's a slam dunk that I should take the adderall by any means, but the fact is that the research does not exist on adderall (and the documented anecdotes suggest an absence of harm) so it's a judgment call. I certainly see why other people make the judgment call of weaning, but the bolded logic is never particularly persuasive to me because its logical extension is ridiculous. |
| OP here... baby rejected formula tonight! Drank a couple of oz when mixed with BM. I know it takes some getting used to. |
Oh, stop. |
|
Exactly, it's a judgment call since there's a lack of evidence either way. I believe all of us will think hard and make a well thought out decision, whatever that is.
OP, good luck on the formula transition! There's one out there s/he'll take! |
| So wait, is the answer nobody has done it? I'd love to hear that perspective! |
+1. At some point I don't think breastfeeding is so beneficial as to warrant either the mother not taking meds she needs or taking the meds to the possible detriment of the child. Formula is not a terrible thing! |