Pumpkin Pie from Libby's canned pumpkin
![[Post New]](/jforum/templates/default/images/icon_minipost_new.gif){kind=icon}
Anonymous
|
Why not just buy real squash and make your on filling? It's actually pretty easy to do.
He's one simple recipe http://www.tasteofhome.com/recipes/butternut-squash-pie 
|
Anonymous
| Did you remember to take the eggs out of the shells? |
Anonymous
| My dad and I roasted a sugar pumpkin. Super easy. So much pumpkin! The flavor of the pie is so delicate and floral |
Anonymous
| I thought it very strange to get grit in my pumpkin--thought it was a fluke. Then, I bought another can a few months later at a different store. This can was MUCH worse for the amount of grit! It's unbelievable! I kept taking bites and tried to identify what the grit was--I was afraid I'd break a tooth. If you've ever gotten sand in your food when picnicing at the beach, then you know! It's SAND! I certainly won't buy Libby's again. I just hope it's not in other brands. BTW, I did not cook the pumpkin. I'm on Atkins and just added cream cheese and cinnamon, Splenda. No sand in in my cinnamon or Splenda :-[ |
Anonymous
| What a random thread to pop up as a zombie... |
Anonymous
| The canned pumpkin from Trader Joe's, organic canned pumpkin from Whole Foods, and Simple Truth pumpkin from Kroger stores has never given me issues. I just used Libby's for some pumpkin waffles and every other bite had grit. Very annoying. I'll go back to my tried and true brands. |
Anonymous
I'm sure the original poster from 2013 will be happy to hear that. |
Anonymous
| This is a REALLY OLD THREAD but I wanted to add I have never had a problem with Libby's pumpkin. In fact, it tastes better and has a better texture than the organic canned pumpkin that I bought one time. I just made two Libby's pies last month (using almond milk to keep it dairy free) and they were delicious. Even my skeptical kids ate it. |
Anonymous
It is Feb. 20, 2017, I just whipped up 2 pumpkin pies today using Libby's 100% pumpkin and there was grit in every bite...I won't buy it again. This happened Thanksgiving 2015 too! 
|
Anonymous
Never had that problem. Think it must be something in your prep. |
Anonymous
+1 And I've made a lot of pumpkin pies. Libby's is my first choice after finding other brands to be watery. |
Anonymous
| I have made and bought a lot of pumpkin products in my time, and I have to say almost every pumpkin product that I have consumed has had some kind of grit/sand in it, whether it be a little or a lot. Those of us that have noticed this know that it could be nothing other than sand/rock. I have yet to try organic, so maybe I'll give that a shot the next time around. |
Anonymous
Just tried a chocolate cake recipe which substituted Libby's canned pumpkin (not the pumpkin pie mix) for the oil or butter and while the flavor, texture and moistness we wonderful, the grit was not! Good heavens, what a waste. Will definitely try Trader Joe's or Whole Food brands! By the way, I also purchased some Libby's mandarin oranges, and found that they were a product of CHINA! If I ever need canned mandarin oranges again, I definitely will get Trader Joe's which are not from China. 
|
Anonymous
same here. My mom has been making it for as long as I can remember to. |
Anonymous
| Four-year-old thread, folks. |