Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I really laugh at how riduculous this requirement is. My kid is in his 6th year of German. We went last summer and he could hardly speak a lick and could not understand much and he is an A student. Its an absolute dog and pony here in the US. There is absoulty NO mastery unless you are in some sort of immersion program or have parents who speak it at home.[/quote]
And yet others do master it. My daughter did in Japanese and DS in Spanish, then German. The requirement is not "ridiculous" for the reason you give. Elite schools think they are educating citizens of the world who will need to deal in multiple languages in a complex business world. That's why they require it.
Well I do a ton of business internationally, as my territory is the pacrim and I have never once had to conduct a business meeting in anyting, but English. Never have I ever even needed and interperetor.
I think it is GREAT to be fluent in another language, I'm fluent in Ukrainian and proficient in Russian. However, it is highly unusual to become fluent in a language without immersion. I find it very hard to believe your kids could possibly carry on a business conversation in any of the languages they have studied in school. My kids have been immersed in Ukrainian and still speak poorly. Cerntainly not well enough to sound educated in a business meeting as a "citizen of the world"