It should not matter what the education level or SES of the families are. You are taking a test based on the content and curriculum of a course being taught. If the course is rigorous and covers all the relevant material then the kids should at least score a 3 minimum which is not hard to do. But 4 and 5 is what your standards should be. I took a number of AP courses, did not study for any of the exams and easily got 3 no problem, some 4’s. Just walked in and took the test. |
No offense but why should I set standards for my kids based on your personal, subjective experience with AP tests back in some random high school somewhere? |
A 3 on the AP exam is not easy for many students even with excellent teachers and alignment of the course to the test. A 3 is relatively easy for a student with excellent reading comprehension skills, strong critical thinking skills, and who can read and write with above average speed. Most of those things a studrnts brings with them to the AP class. As an AP teacher i can say that some of my proudest achievements are getting my students who don’t have those skills at the start of the course to earn a 2. Note this is for a science AP. To be honest most motivated kids that earn 4 and 5’s don’t need a particularly strong teacher to get them there. |
Set whatever standard you want. You want lower standards feel free. But you won’t be getting any college credits with a 3. Their standard to mastering the course and getting credit has always been a 4 or 5. 3 is mediocre and if that is the standard you want to set, go for it. |
Huh? |
You're right, it shouldn't. But anyone who's spent 10 seconds paying attention knows SES makes a huge difference (in average, of course) in all educational outcomes. |
NP but I think PP is saying a 3 doesn’t really mean much. And they’re right. It doesn’t get college credit, doesn’t indicate mastery of content, etc. |
We are not talking about general outcomes. We are talking about a course designed for advance students to master the content and prove so by scoring a 4 or 5. Above is obviously not the intent in AP for all in DCPS. That is where the problem lies. Then the curriculum and class is watered down. |
I give that post a 1. |
You need to spend more than 10 seconds thinking about this. The research is very clear that it is the education level of the parents that drives educational outcomes for kids. Of course, parents who are highly educated tend to make more money but the causality for student educational outcomes is parental education level. |
The “socio” part of socioeconomic includes education level. Anyway the point is that virtually all white adults in DC have college degrees, and no other demographic group tracked by OSSE is anywhere near so uniform in terms of parental education. So if you want to know about the outcomes at a particular school for students whose parents have college degrees, the OSSE data for white students is a pretty good proxy. Just bear in mind that you’re using a proxy stat, and there are a lot of non-white adults in DC with college degrees, too. And yes, parents’ education level shouldn’t matter to AP/IB pass rate, but it does. In fact I suspect that the reason the College Board prefers to report 3+ data, rather than the 4+ data everyone here would prefer to see, is that there’s an even stronger correlation for 4+. |
But getting a 5 on an AP exam like AP Chemistry or AP Physics is a big accomplishment. Only about 10% of students across the US get a 5 in these specific exams. A 3 on these exams is pretty good. You won’t get to skip the intro college courses for these subjects with an AP score of a 3 but when you take the college course, it should be significantly easier for the student than if they never took the AP class |
|
PP and I agree with your take but most kids just want AP scores for college credit or admissions. A three doesn’t really accomplish much in either of those areas. |
|