Forum Index
»
Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS)
The demographics of our county have changed significantly in the last 10-15 years. We should not be relying on decades old data to make these decisions. |
They mean that in the event of inclement weather closures requiring makeup days, they could open school on non-instructional days that are also religious observances. |
That's not how I read it. The point is not to have to open school a week earlier. The way to do that is to open up on religious holidays instead. |
But the survey said "Identifying days of religious observance as inclement weather makeup days." |
You know nothing about how the first week of school goes. Obviously. If the majority of students aren’t there the first week because they had planned vacations based on the calendar, guess what the second week looks like? A repeat of week 1. So no. No instructional time is gained by doing this. |
they need to access a new demographic survey. They can't issue a survey because everyone would be everything in order to keep the days off. |
The majority of students will be there for the first week. Do you think everyone in the county has already booked a non-refundable vacation in mid-August? Extremely unlikely |
+1. My kids will be there. There are very few camps that week. I had taken a few days off that week to spend with them before they go back to school but the plans we have can be changed. It’s still 4 months away-most people can adjust. |
Of course everyone can adjust. For some people it will cost money. For many they will miss things they planned and looked forward to. Will teachers that booked non-refundable trips show up? I guess we'll see. And the question is to what end. To barely comply with a state mandate to end the school year before Juneteenth? What is the actual goal here? Do they care at all about how they have reduced scheduled instructional days over the years such that it seems every year they need to add useless makeup days at the end to comply with the state while teachers and families scrambled? They aren't changing anything that will actually fix that situation. They are just ensuring it keeps happening. |
| we always plan a trip that week specifically because there aren't camps as do many families at our school. I can't imagine everyone is going to be okay with making the choice to either eat the cost or miss the first week. it is simply too late to make this type of change for 4 months out. why can't they just reduce winter break by 2-3 days, cut easter monday, and maybe a planning day and then you're done? |
| Starting early is the best option. Summer is too long anyway. Fairfax county used to start after labor day and now they start around the 17th of August or so. |
You aren’t very thoughtful. Excused absences pit a large burden on the child. My child has a 504 for medical issues and misses many classes already for medical treatments. These are all excused. He finds it hard to keep up with missed. It’s really difficult to make up missed assignments and exams, but it’s even harder to catch up on misses lessons. Despite the 504, his grades can suffer because of the snowball effect and limited time to make up for missed classes. Missing for religious holidays would further compound that. So even though all these would be excused absences, it essentially punishes the student. |
Well there are a lot of families who have also planned their winter breaks. They can use the same argument. Especially immigrant families who do international travel over winter break since summer is too hot in their home country. Winter break is not long enough to begin with. Fairfax county gets 2 weeks of winter break. |
Where is the line though? What percentage of students and teachers being out should trigger a day off? 2-3% is not a substantial enough population IMO. What about your kid? It’s not equitable they have to miss because of their disability so should all of her classmates miss school any time she does? You might like that but if we implemented that it would mean we would never have school. It just doesn’t work. We need to find a way to help those catch up from excused absences in some other way, not just cancel school. |
Actually, a special law was passed to let them count hours in AA. |