What world do you live in? Unless OP is in a position to make sure that the cat never ever leaves her home (which sound unlikely), the cat will kill LOTS of animals. They're truly an absolute menace from an environmental point of view. Some countries recognize how much wildlife they kill and they're trying to cull the cats. If you truly cared about animals and saving innocent lives, you'd take it to a shelter where they put in an injection and the cat falls asleep and doesn't wake up. It's the best thing to save the lives of innocent animals. |
^^ Should add, I've had several cats through my life and wouldn't want to see OP's mom's cat die, if a way can be found to avoid that. But continuing to let OP's mom's cat outdoors is totally wrong, and that's what I was reacting to. |
Didn't fix it for me at all. |
Cats are super low maintenance, actually. I understand your feelings but I think you're overstating the work involved. If you keep the kitty, and I think you should (I certainly would), I'd ask your mom/sister to help with vet bills and I'd keep the cat inside. |
|
fyi to another PP...I have the Roomba (not the one with the wifi, just the basic one) and I love it so much I bought another one. It's incredible what it picks up.
OP, I vote to try out the cat, and also, since this situation is temporary, see if someone you know will foster the cat until sibling arrives. I'm not a cat person, but a dog-cat cat is so worth trying to hang on to. And don't worry about turning it into an indoor cat--better than being a shelter cat. |
I’ll never understand people who think a cat, even their pet, has more of a right to fun (predation) than the right to life of hundreds of native species—and by extension, the local ecosystem. Do a better job of entertaining your cat inside your house. OP, I’d adopt the cat, but you’re absolutely right to want to keep it indoors. |
I'll never understand why people think that it's OK to keep a cat locked up indoors for its whole life. Live in an area where you think that a cat outdoors will kill native species? Then don't get a cat. I don't have a cat for this very reason. |
ALL cats kill native species. Even Fluffy. By your logic, nobody should own a cat. Especially not apartment dwellers. Another problem with your logic is that it’s based on the false assumption that cats always need to go outside. They don’t. Put some effort into entertaining/petting your cat and it will be fine. |
I don't have a cat. |
It sounds like you’re saying nobody should ever have a housecat? Because your argument sounds like: 1. Cats need to/must/should go outside, but 2. Outside they unavoidably kill native critters. Is that what you’re saying? I’m with you on the second point. But if you realized the first point was silly, you could relax this prohibition on owning housecats. |
|
Cats want to go outside because they’re hunters. They want to hunt. And roam to hunt. Which are exactly the two reasons why they shouldn’t be let out.
You don’t have the right to kill wildlife, and you don’t have the right to be on your neighbors’ properties. You are responsible for your pets, so keep them on your property. If that don’t jive with your opinion of the best life for a cat and that’s something that bothers you, then don’t get one. |
Cats want to go outside, but they don't have to. Many get used to staying indoors, that is if the owners do the work of providing stimulation and love. Otherwise, this logic leads to the conclusion that nobody should own cats. |
| OP here. So we decided based on your suggestions to take the cat on a trial basis. It actually hasn’t been bad at all and my kids absolutely love him. Sadly, my toddler seems to have a cat allergy - his nose is constantly stuffy now, especially at night and this is the only thing that’s changed. We are actually really sad about having to rehome him now! |
OP thanks so much for the update! I am glad you decided to take in the kitty. Sorry to hear your toddler has allergies. I have had cats all my adult life. I am mildly allergic to them. I find that I build up an immunity to each new cat within 2-3 months though, so I just tough it out until then. But I am not a toddler, which is a whole different thing. If you want to try for a few more weeks, try vacuuming. Often. Like OCD often. And dust. And wash blankets often wherever kitty has been sleeping. And windows open as much as is feasible. |
| It’s tree pollen season. Give it some time. |