|
I’ve seen cases where students with MAP scores in the 290s didn’t get into Blair SMACS, and considering that the median MAP Math score for admitted students is 273, it seems like MAP scores alone aren’t the deciding factor. My kid told me that most of the students around him have scores in the 270s, which makes me think his peer group might not be the very top tier. I also heard that some 8th graders are taking Algebra 2. My kid got into TPMS through the lottery (but got into CES based on their scores—99th percentile on the CogAT and MAP- m). I’ve also heard that one of the middle schools in the W cluster offers Algebra 2. Either way, there are just so many strong students in MCPS. My guess is that a 99th percentile MAP score elsewhere might be more like the 90th percentile in MCPS. Like I mentioned before, my kid is great at writing essays. He loves insects and animals and has been raising and observing all kinds of bugs, spiders, and arthropods at home. He’s gone to nature center camps every year and spend weekends at nature centers, parks, and the natural history museum. He wrote all of that honestly in his essay, and it really fit the Global Ecology program perfectly. But in the end, he didn’t get invited to Blair. He did make the waitpool, maybe that’s because of his high MAP Math score? |
It sounds like PHS ecology program is a better fit for your kid and he picked the better choice. SMACS curriculum at Blair does have labs and field trips, but really not impressive to me. It's not even comparable to my HS experience when I did it at a developing country 20+ years ago. But the math, cs and physics curriculum and choices are super, and teachers of these classes are absolutely the real treasure for maintaining the excellency of this program. So for kids that are really in love with math, coding, universe or engineering, SMACS is a better choice. For kids who want to become a doctor or a biologist, he/she should have a second thought. |
| My kid is in wait pool for GE in PHS . Do anyone of you think if there is still a chance of him getting into it ? |
DP. DC was accepted to SMACS and GE. They very much want to be a doctor, and biology is their favorite subject, but not field trips, they would never observe insects or ask to go to nature museum. But they are very interested genetics, evolution, "the logic" of human body, cells, immune system etc, as it were. Any advice? |
Yes. The chances are significant. |
DP, would you mind sharing your kid's MAP-M, MAP-R? |
Is your child 9th or 10th? The bio electives at Blair are super and there are a ton of them. |
If they don't like field trips SMACS. The field trips are fun if you like that sort of thing. If you don't it just gives you more things to make up because they don't cancel math or other classes on those days. |
PP here. I have a lot of friends working at NIH, JHU, and other top labs in this area, and the majority of us agree the biology curriculum is less impressive. I myself had phd in math + phys in college, and working in CS domain now. Although the AI-related courses are very outdated, other courses I mentioned above are quite impressive. Those teachers are knowledgable, passionate, hands-on, and humble. |
how does the blair biology curriculum compare to strong home HS? |
In addition to advanced bio which all magnet kids take in 10th, Blair offers cellular physiology, marine biology, neuroscience, genetic analysis, foundations of immunology |
Thank you. I saw the list of electives and they titles sound good on paper. I was just wondering about the quality of courses compared to what the student get at their home (W) school, since you seem to have some first hand experience with the kids in the program. |
I don’t have experience with other schools but, I don’t think any of those classes are available elsewhere except marine biology. The teachers at Blair are excellent and the classes go into more depth than anywhere else. It is not, however, a program that focuses on APs. |
| PHS and Global more narrowly have an inferiority complex. I think PHS Poolesville SMCS is highly regarded by many of the kids go to Global as their last choice and have a chip on their shoulders for not getting in to other programs. There will be kids who really enjoy the subject and are into insects or animals or conservation but the vast majority will be there wishing they had gotten into RMIB or Blair or PHS SMCS |