We've got January 29th, April 10th, and April 22nd as make-up dates without that problem. Yes, we might run out of good options if MCPS keeps closing, but there are very, very good options for our current situation. And next year they really need to go back to scheduling 184 days to begin with. |
If only we had make-up days that didn't interfere with "end of the year, summer vacations, spring break, [or] spring break vacations." Oh wait, we do! Three of them! |
Yes… one is Eid, and another is Passover. I expect we shouldn’t continue disenfranchising religious groups |
If it really offends your sensibilities that much to have school on religious holidays, then you should have made that comment when they created the calendar. The reality is, though, those are already holidays celebrated at night. And there are far too many religious holidays to avoid them all. We bend over for religions too much as it is. You do you, but it isn't reasonable to impact everyone else. |
Totally agree. The calendar only accommodates a few religions. Many other cultural and religious holidays are not included. It’s already a discrimination there. Maybe no religious holidays is fair to everyone. |
|
Asynchronous days don’t work for every other county. I have a friend with a 5th grader in PG. They have scheduled asynchronous days built in just because. Monday is one. So my friend has to stay home from work for the day. Last time the teachers didn’t post the work until during the day they were supposed to be doing it. My friends kid logged in at 8am to see what needed doing. One assignment was posted. Another one was posted at 10am and another one at 1pm. Meanwhile the kid did the one from 8am and shut the computer off thinking she was done. She got 0s for the other work.
So don’t say other county’s are doing it right, because they’re not. |
We have one that belongs to my high school kid for gaming. Otherwise we have work computers- we do have a tablet but that is not going to get the job done. |
Next year's calendar is already approved with 182 days. |
So you think your one anecdote is proof it's not working for everyone. Got it. |
Your statement really highlights our struggle and your ignorance. Eid holidays are NOT celebrated only at night. That’s just when the Muslim day begins. Eid prayer happens in the morning the day after. Families get together generally AFTER that as well for lunches and dinners and visits to friends. We’ve had so many years where we didn’t even get the day off, that it was even progress for them to give the day as a professional day. We’ve been lobbying (unsuccessfully) for them to make it a full day off for teachers also, as they do for TWO Jewish high holidays. The Muslim teachers we have struggle to get the day off because it’s hard to get permission to take days off reserved for planning and development—and they have to use one of their ONLY 3 or so available days. Muslim students for years just accepted that the system didn’t recognize or care about their holidays. They would either not celebrate at all or have to make up work on their own time somehow. So when the school system gives us the day as a planning day, that’s already the result of decades of struggle for recognition. Because our holiday shifts, we didn’t even ask for 2 days for something like a decade because one Eid was in the summer. Something tells me they will refuse to recognize them again once they come back to the beginning of the school year, when they cannot be clawed back as makeup days. |
Sure. Secular holidays only. Which is basically what it is already. |
What makes you think they can't update it? |
You make a very good arguement detailing why it would be silly and short-sighted to fight it as a make-up day. If it can't actually be used as a make-ip day, it's probably going to be an annually-scheduled school day. If you actually want to preserve Eid as a day off, then focus you'd be better off pushing *for* a different day, rather than pushing *against* Eid. January 29th would be a popular choice among parents, if you can get MCEA to agree to a full day. |
Why not get Central Office to agree that grades are not due until 2/2? |
The 184 day calendar would only be useful if they gave back the days we didn't use. |