EDP sub rules?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Everybody is way too caught up in the alphabet soup of leagues. Until now I’ve just quietly sat back and not commented on the elitist attitudes. There are strong players in every league. My kid plays in EDP and *gasp* not even EDP 1. He plays there because MLS Next wouldn’t allow him to play HS. He practiced with the team a few times and the coach was honest that he would probably not have much playing time. It wasn’t worth it to miss the HS season with friends and have the stress of playing that high level just to sit on the bench. He considered ECNL teams but they were all far and it was going to be a pain getting to/from practice. Plus, he would miss too much club due to HS where the coach thinks he owns the kids and benches the kids who miss. I’m sure the ECNL coaches would feel the same. Sure he could have skipped HS but it’s what makes HS fun for him. Yes, we know Potomac now has ECNL which would make the whole thing a lot easier but we commited to his team before we knew of that development. A bunch of kids from his team did wind up at ECNL this year so clearly EDP has kids that are that level.

We know a family that spent the last decade jumping from elite team to elite team. They swore their daughter would be playing D1. The entire family’s life revolved around traveling around the country for tournaments. Is she good? Yes! But there were no D1 offers. She is going D3, full pay. And guess what? So are a bunch of boys who played HS varsity soccer and EDP.

We can see the difference between our kid and the top players. We have no delusions. We have always known he isn’t going D1 and probably not playing in college D3 (though he’d like to). I really don’t understand why people on here feel the need to put down leagues and teams that others may be happy with. I understand if a post is seeking guidance about levels but this thread is simply about EDP sub rules. If your child is so talented as to be playing at the highest level, why bother posting here?

Oh goodness, another one of these.
Can't we all just accept that overall, and knowing that there are always exceptions, that MLS Next is the strongest leage overall, followed by ECNL, followed by EDP?

Other than the excessive travel, expenses and marketing aesthetics, ECNL is EDP.
No ambitious EDP player is saying, I'm going to take a step up to ECNL on my way to MLS Next. It's straight to MLS Next.

You are crazy if you think EDP = ECNL. Now you may find one of the strongest EDPs teams in a particular age group may be competitive and even beat the weakest ECNL team but in general, this is a crazy statement and if you think colleges look at EDP the same way they look at ECNL, that's even crazier! but you do you.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Everybody is way too caught up in the alphabet soup of leagues. Until now I’ve just quietly sat back and not commented on the elitist attitudes. There are strong players in every league. My kid plays in EDP and *gasp* not even EDP 1. He plays there because MLS Next wouldn’t allow him to play HS. He practiced with the team a few times and the coach was honest that he would probably not have much playing time. It wasn’t worth it to miss the HS season with friends and have the stress of playing that high level just to sit on the bench. He considered ECNL teams but they were all far and it was going to be a pain getting to/from practice. Plus, he would miss too much club due to HS where the coach thinks he owns the kids and benches the kids who miss. I’m sure the ECNL coaches would feel the same. Sure he could have skipped HS but it’s what makes HS fun for him. Yes, we know Potomac now has ECNL which would make the whole thing a lot easier but we commited to his team before we knew of that development. A bunch of kids from his team did wind up at ECNL this year so clearly EDP has kids that are that level.

We know a family that spent the last decade jumping from elite team to elite team. They swore their daughter would be playing D1. The entire family’s life revolved around traveling around the country for tournaments. Is she good? Yes! But there were no D1 offers. She is going D3, full pay. And guess what? So are a bunch of boys who played HS varsity soccer and EDP.

We can see the difference between our kid and the top players. We have no delusions. We have always known he isn’t going D1 and probably not playing in college D3 (though he’d like to). I really don’t understand why people on here feel the need to put down leagues and teams that others may be happy with. I understand if a post is seeking guidance about levels but this thread is simply about EDP sub rules. If your child is so talented as to be playing at the highest level, why bother posting here?

Oh goodness, another one of these.
Can't we all just accept that overall, and knowing that there are always exceptions, that MLS Next is the strongest leage overall, followed by ECNL, followed by EDP?

Other than the excessive travel, expenses and marketing aesthetics, ECNL is EDP.
No ambitious EDP player is saying, I'm going to take a step up to ECNL on my way to MLS Next. It's straight to MLS Next.

You are crazy if you think EDP = ECNL. Now you may find one of the strongest EDPs teams in a particular age group may be competitive and even beat the weakest ECNL team but in general, this is a crazy statement and if you think colleges look at EDP the same way they look at ECNL, that's even crazier! but you do you.

And as far as ECNL vs MLS Next. Colleges look at MLS Next more fondly than ECNL but there are many ECNL teams that beat MLS Next teams locally. My son's ECNL team is about 500% against MLS Next teams over the years, but college coaches regard MLS Next higher and I say that because every year on of MLS Next's showcases conflict directly with an ECNL showcase and the MLS Next showcase gets twice the college coaches as ECNL showcase does. My son has played EDP and guest played with EDP teams. Played EDP Cup twice, etc. No comparison.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Everybody is way too caught up in the alphabet soup of leagues. Until now I’ve just quietly sat back and not commented on the elitist attitudes. There are strong players in every league. My kid plays in EDP and *gasp* not even EDP 1. He plays there because MLS Next wouldn’t allow him to play HS. He practiced with the team a few times and the coach was honest that he would probably not have much playing time. It wasn’t worth it to miss the HS season with friends and have the stress of playing that high level just to sit on the bench. He considered ECNL teams but they were all far and it was going to be a pain getting to/from practice. Plus, he would miss too much club due to HS where the coach thinks he owns the kids and benches the kids who miss. I’m sure the ECNL coaches would feel the same. Sure he could have skipped HS but it’s what makes HS fun for him. Yes, we know Potomac now has ECNL which would make the whole thing a lot easier but we commited to his team before we knew of that development. A bunch of kids from his team did wind up at ECNL this year so clearly EDP has kids that are that level.

We know a family that spent the last decade jumping from elite team to elite team. They swore their daughter would be playing D1. The entire family’s life revolved around traveling around the country for tournaments. Is she good? Yes! But there were no D1 offers. She is going D3, full pay. And guess what? So are a bunch of boys who played HS varsity soccer and EDP.

We can see the difference between our kid and the top players. We have no delusions. We have always known he isn’t going D1 and probably not playing in college D3 (though he’d like to). I really don’t understand why people on here feel the need to put down leagues and teams that others may be happy with. I understand if a post is seeking guidance about levels but this thread is simply about EDP sub rules. If your child is so talented as to be playing at the highest level, why bother posting here?

Oh goodness, another one of these.
Can't we all just accept that overall, and knowing that there are always exceptions, that MLS Next is the strongest leage overall, followed by ECNL, followed by EDP?

Other than the excessive travel, expenses and marketing aesthetics, ECNL is EDP.
No ambitious EDP player is saying, I'm going to take a step up to ECNL on my way to MLS Next. It's straight to MLS Next.

You are crazy if you think EDP = ECNL. Now you may find one of the strongest EDPs teams in a particular age group may be competitive and even beat the weakest ECNL team but in general, this is a crazy statement and if you think colleges look at EDP the same way they look at ECNL, that's even crazier! but you do you.

Is that your official psychiatric evaluation?
College scouts don't recruit teams, they recruit players. Fact or Fiction?

[Anonymous]

Jeez people, is there any thread you can't hijack and kill?
Just go away, please.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Everybody is way too caught up in the alphabet soup of leagues. Until now I’ve just quietly sat back and not commented on the elitist attitudes. There are strong players in every league. My kid plays in EDP and *gasp* not even EDP 1. He plays there because MLS Next wouldn’t allow him to play HS. He practiced with the team a few times and the coach was honest that he would probably not have much playing time. It wasn’t worth it to miss the HS season with friends and have the stress of playing that high level just to sit on the bench. He considered ECNL teams but they were all far and it was going to be a pain getting to/from practice. Plus, he would miss too much club due to HS where the coach thinks he owns the kids and benches the kids who miss. I’m sure the ECNL coaches would feel the same. Sure he could have skipped HS but it’s what makes HS fun for him. Yes, we know Potomac now has ECNL which would make the whole thing a lot easier but we commited to his team before we knew of that development. A bunch of kids from his team did wind up at ECNL this year so clearly EDP has kids that are that level.

We know a family that spent the last decade jumping from elite team to elite team. They swore their daughter would be playing D1. The entire family’s life revolved around traveling around the country for tournaments. Is she good? Yes! But there were no D1 offers. She is going D3, full pay. And guess what? So are a bunch of boys who played HS varsity soccer and EDP.

We can see the difference between our kid and the top players. We have no delusions. We have always known he isn’t going D1 and probably not playing in college D3 (though he’d like to). I really don’t understand why people on here feel the need to put down leagues and teams that others may be happy with. I understand if a post is seeking guidance about levels but this thread is simply about EDP sub rules. If your child is so talented as to be playing at the highest level, why bother posting here?

Oh goodness, another one of these.
Can't we all just accept that overall, and knowing that there are always exceptions, that MLS Next is the strongest leage overall, followed by ECNL, followed by EDP?

Other than the excessive travel, expenses and marketing aesthetics, ECNL is EDP.
No ambitious EDP player is saying, I'm going to take a step up to ECNL on my way to MLS Next. It's straight to MLS Next.

You are crazy if you think EDP = ECNL. Now you may find one of the strongest EDPs teams in a particular age group may be competitive and even beat the weakest ECNL team but in general, this is a crazy statement and if you think colleges look at EDP the same way they look at ECNL, that's even crazier! but you do you.

And as far as ECNL vs MLS Next. Colleges look at MLS Next more fondly than ECNL but there are many ECNL teams that beat MLS Next teams locally. My son's ECNL team is about 500% against MLS Next teams over the years, but college coaches regard MLS Next higher and I say that because every year on of MLS Next's showcases conflict directly with an ECNL showcase and the MLS Next showcase gets twice the college coaches as ECNL showcase does. My son has played EDP and guest played with EDP teams. Played EDP Cup twice, etc. No comparison.

You think that college coaches focus on MLS Professional Club Academies and MLS Next Teams more than ECNL because of the timing of the showcases?
The rosters of D1 College soccer teams are filled with International Players and MLS Club Academy players then MLS Next players, then.
It actually says so right there on the rosters.

Your emotions and opinions doesn't alter facts.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Jeez people, is there any thread you can't hijack and kill?
Just go away, please.

Someone answered the question and posted the rules from the EDP website on page 1 of the thread

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Jeez people, is there any thread you can't hijack and kill?
Just go away, please.

Someone answered the question and posted the rules from the EDP website on page 1 of the thread

And it was becoming an interesting discussion on whether the rule actually benefits anyone before it was taken over by the "my league is better than yours" trolls.