Forum Index
»
College and University Discussion
| Kid wants stem, VT a better option. |
Go away. This is irrelevant. |
UVA is not using GPA to compare applicants within a school. |
Sure they're not. For each of the 50-100 kids from each school in their 3-5 minute review, they are individually assesssing all 40+ classes they have taken, considering the strength of each class, how tough the teacher is, whether the grade is reflective of the student's ability. Come on. They look at GPA, count the APs, make sure there is max rigor, make sure there are no straight Bs or worse, if there are look for an explanation and/or upward trend. There simply isn't time for the type of granular review people are dreaming about. If one kid has a 4.4 and another has a 4.2, 99 times out of a hundred the 4.4 kid is getting in and the 4.2 isn't. The data bears this out year after year. It isn't that complicated. |
They do all this minus GPA. Dean J confirmed. I don’t know why this is so hard for you. Maybe you need to feel like you’re in control, maybe you always have to be right. You’re not. Let it go. UVA doesn’t use GPA. |
Why are you so triggered by the reality that some schools are better than others? We’re fortunate in VA to have highly regarded state schools. |
The disagreement is UVA boosters tend to exaggerate the perceived superiority. UVA could be marginally better in some cases, but it’s a state school just like many other decent state schools. DP |
Ok, so the message is to get the best grades possible in the hardest classes available in all core courses? That probably won't impact your GPA. |
GPA isn’t how that is measured at UVA. Maybe that’s how you measure, and that okay. UVA doesn’t need your permission to disregard GPA. How about you message Dean J? Report back, I’d love to hear her response since apparently you know more. |
This no true! UVA #1 stem |
UVA is #1 college ever! HYP bow down to the University! |
Because people here want practical information and are trying to figure out if their kids have a chance of getting in. Telling people we have a secret method that we can't explain isn't helpful. We can agree that UVA wants max rigor in core classes - they say that all of the time. We can agree they want top grades in those core classes - they say that all of the time. We should be able to agree that if you are at school X and you take max rigor and get top grades then you will have a certain GPA or GPA range based on how grade weights are assigned at that school - that is just math. Here is what else Dean J said: "GPA doesn't tell the whole story." We can assume it tells some of the story. "Resist the urge to compare your numbers to students outside your school." We can assume comparing numbers within a school makes some sense. Looking at Naviance or Scoir, you will see that kids above a certain range almost certainly get admitted, and below a certain range almost certainly get rejected. There is a fairly narrow middle range where all of the other stuff probably plays a larger role. Whether UVA uses the school's GPA number or looks at the transcript for class strength and grades and comes to the same conclusion is irrelevant - GPA is reflective of rigor and performance, which is what UVA claims to care about. So for parent's trying to assess their kid's chances, instead of saying you will have to just apply and guess how UVA might review your classes and grades, much better advice is to talk to you school's counselor and look at the actual data that is available to you. It tells a pretty clear story. |
Again, YOU might find GPA useful, but that doesn’t mean UVA uses GPA. You said it yourself, you’re assuming. |
They don't "score" these transcripts when they need to evaluate against many thousands of applications? I don't see how that is practicable. |
+1. Precisely. The first thing the readers do is compare the applicant’s GPA to the school profile sent by the college counselor. Then courses taken to those offered to check rigor. Then the student is compared to other applicants from the high school. Then test scores, then hooks. It’s absurd to say UVA doesn’t look at grades, especially when SCHEV reports that this past fall’s class had a 4.5 at the 75th percentile and a 4.4 at the median. If UVA doesn’t look at GPA, then where did those VA-reported GPAs come from? |