Sure, Jan. I wonder why almost no Sidwell US students transfer to other high schools (unless they can’t handle Sidwell’s academic workload—there’s 1-2 every year). Other than that, this is more cope from the poors. 🤣 |
| Seriously. These Sidwell parents and boosters on DCUM are an embarrassment. |
Poor people (Sidwell parents) they don’t have any other outlet to express themselves and look normal at the same time. |
Yet I’m so not embarrassed…because my children attend Sidwell. 😊 There is literally no other school in the DMV I would want them to attend. |
I am so glad that my identity or source of happiness is not attached to the school my kids attend. My kids go to a great school, but they could have gone to another good school and I would be comfortable with that. |
We love Stuyvesant. We applaud their hard work and success. And while Stuyvesant nominally sends more kids to T20 than almost any other school its still less than 1/3 of their graduating class. We wish them greater success in the future. Go solve fusion. Go make robots. Go fix global warming. Trinity is much smaller and nominally send far fewer students to T20 but it sends more than half. We have parents here that went to the Stuyvesant. They have no interest in sending their kids to Stuyvesant. If you have a choice, you send your kids to one of maybe a dozen private schools in NYC over Stuyvesant. We love Stuyvesant and what it says about merit and social mobility but the competition is brutal and it doesn't really get you as much of a feeder effect as the better independent schools. And more importantly it doesn't really prepare you for college better than the top private schools outside of a very narrow range of STEM areas. If you can afford it, you can have high rigor without the trauma inducing competition and end up with better writing and speaking skills than you would get at any of the public schools. |
If you can go to Sidwell, you should go to Sidwell over TJ unless you are hyperspiked in STEM. If you have a superspike in STEM, TJ is very hard to beat. |
Omg, amazingly, you could swap out the schools for DC ones and see the exact same argument made over here! |
I agree. If you are hardcore “STEM or bust” (and you must attend a top 10 tech school), then you should definitely pick TJ over Sidwell. Otherwise, nope. |
I think both of you are neglecting to account for differences in preferences. Nobody is turning up their nose at Yale, Brown or even Dartmouth but a lot of people from the TJs and Stuyvesants of the world are more eager to attend CMU, GA Tech, or UIUC. Most private school kids don't have the same interest in STEM that the magnet school kids have. Also NYC is not DC Sidwell/NCS/STA/GDA doesn't have NYC affluence. TJ doesn't have NYC poverty. |
What are you talking about that TJ doesn't have NYC poverty??? That made no sense especially when paired with a lack of affluences in the privates. Yes, there is more extreme wealth in NYC than there is in DC, but there isn't a significant difference in the amount of poverty. Further there is still some extreme wealth in DC that specifically sends its kids to private school. |
| Sadwell No Friends! |
We’re on page 19 talking about a school’s nickname that was created by some haters. As Beyonce said, you know you’re that b when you cause all this conversation. Sidwell, you’re that b! 🤣 |
Specially the parents. |
Something like 10% of TJ is on free/reduced school lunch. Something like 50% of Stuyvesant is on free/reduced school lunch. TJ doesn't have NYC poverty. The median family income at Big 3 does not really compare to the median family incomes at top NYC privates. Big 3 do not have NYC affluence. |