1. No, my numbers are more up to date than those links. 2. BASIS does not draw randomly, it draws according to sibling preference which perpetuates its existing demographics, and has poor retention of certain populations. Lottery is not the only factor in shaping the school. Deal is only 78% in-boundary and receives students from many elementary schools and locations. 3. This isn't about 9th, it's about you explaining how Deal and BASIS have equivalent performance despite BASIS having certain advantages. |
I'm not sure, but you can see here that in the prior lottery year they did take a few kids straight from the lottery, who were by definition OOB. https://public.tableau.com/app/profile/aaron2446/viz/MSDCSeatsandWaitlistOfferData_draft/MSDCPublicDisplay |
Actually, it is not the high school number because it tracks the attendance for the whole school (it is mislabeled as "high school" ). In any event, the report card shows the following for 2022, which is pretty similar for Basis and Deal to the earlier numbers: Basis: 9% Deal: 10% Hardy: 14% Just for comparison, let's look at the following: Janney <1% Key 2% Mann 2% Lafayette 3% |
your strawman questions? why would they? |
You are ignoring the biggest advantage: Deal draws students from the richest part of DC. |
Nobody gets more than a 5 on the PARCC no matter how rich they are. BASIS draws kids from high-income families too. That is why BASIS has such a low at-risk percentage. |
Where are you getting that 9% from? Regardless of its feeders, Deal somehow ends up at 10%-- I'm really not sure how. |
What? Why would BASIS make the 10th graders take the Algebra 1 PARCC when the 7th graders are the ones actually taking that class? |
Probably because the high schoolers have to take something to fulfill the PARCC requirements, and Algebra 1, 2, and Geometry are the only choices. But it does mean that students don't necessarily take the test for the class they are taking. |
its kinda shocking how the white student data is pretty uniform across schools - there isn't that much of a gap between the best and worst. But if you look at minority performance, there is a huge gap.
Looking at english language, of the 37 DCPS schools with enough white students for data, all but 2 have >70% passing rates (exceptions are Mann and Bruce-Monroe). Look at AA students, you have schools that range from 90% pass rates to under 5% pass rates. Ross has 81% of AA students pass, and Savoy ES has under 5%. Sidenote, at walls - who are the 18 students who can't read/write. Are they just those who didn't answer any questions and just turned in a blank piece of paper? (I know people who did this when we had state standardized tests back in the day and just read a book in the hallway) |
I don't think they have to take any PARCC at all if they aren't in those classes. That's why you see so little data for 11th and 12th graders. |
Empower dashboard shows the percent at risk at each school relative to their PARCC performance. I see 7% for BASIS, so lower at risk vs. Deal at 10%. https://www.empowerk12.org/data-dashboard-source/dc-parcc-dash |
They don't take the PARCC. |
It seems like BASIS does better with its at risk kids than Deal does. |
Looks the JKLM schools are broken up.
Guess it now is JSLRK. Ross and Stoddert are both significantly better than Mann/Murch now. Is Mann even a decent school in DC accounting for demographics (with Ross as the best)? Kinda shocking. School Name Subject Percent Stoddert Elementary School Math 83.05 Janney Elementary School Math 81.57 Lafayette Elementary School Math 81.36 Ross Elementary School Math 78.33 Key Elementary School Math 73.88 Murch Elementary School Math 71.26 Mann Elementary School Math 67.29 Hearst Elementary School Math 66.90 Eaton Elementary School Math 62.90 Oyster-Adams Bilingual School Math 62.71 School Name Subject Percent Janney Elementary School ELA 88.19 Ross Elementary School ELA 86.66 Key Elementary School ELA 80.25 Stoddert Elementary School ELA 77.52 Lafayette Elementary School ELA 77.19 Eaton Elementary School ELA 76.75 Murch Elementary School ELA 67.41 Hearst Elementary School ELA 67.39 Oyster-Adams Bilingual School ELA 65.95 Mann Elementary School ELA 62.42 |