How much do you make and how much FA do you receive?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

I see it differently -- you found way to have other people provide your children a very good education and still allow you and your family to live the life you want to live.

+1 I agree. No other way to spin it.

And to expand on that you found way to have other people provide your children a very good education and still allow you and your family to live the life you want to live while simultaneously depriving truly needy children of the financial aid that could help their families escape the school-to-prison pipeline. But enjoy your vacation.

Exactly!!!!

Oh, poppycock. FA departments want a mix of middle- and low-income kids. PP isn't depriving anyone. If she didn't apply, that money would go to another middle class student.

massive rationalization. It's how one get's over a guilty conscience.

Not PP, but we get FA and feel 0% guilty about it. Grateful? Yes. Guilty? Hell no. Nobody's forcing the school to give us aid. They want my kid, they offered the aid, I accepted. Why would I feel guilty?

You are ridiculous.

Aren't we defensive...

No she isn't defensive. She is matter of fact. You on the other hand...jealous much?

Instead of beating up on the PP you should ask her how they managed to pull off getting FA so you can do the same. It's clear your jealously is killing you.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

I see it differently -- you found way to have other people provide your children a very good education and still allow you and your family to live the life you want to live.

+1 I agree. No other way to spin it.

And to expand on that you found way to have other people provide your children a very good education and still allow you and your family to live the life you want to live while simultaneously depriving truly needy children of the financial aid that could help their families escape the school-to-prison pipeline. But enjoy your vacation.

Exactly!!!!

Oh, poppycock. FA departments want a mix of middle- and low-income kids. PP isn't depriving anyone. If she didn't apply, that money would go to another middle class student.

massive rationalization. It's how one get's over a guilty conscience.

Not PP, but we get FA and feel 0% guilty about it. Grateful? Yes. Guilty? Hell no. Nobody's forcing the school to give us aid. They want my kid, they offered the aid, I accepted. Why would I feel guilty?

You are ridiculous.

Aren't we defensive...

No she isn't defensive. She is matter of fact. You on the other hand...jealous much?

Instead of beating up on the PP you should ask her how they managed to pull off getting FA so you can do the same. It's clear your jealously is killing you.

You also have no idea how much money any of these people make. They might be able to go on a vacation but might have a home with a low mortgage in a less desirable area, might not buy lots of new clothes, might not belong to a country club and might not eat out very often - just a few examples. Everyone has different priorities and spending habits. Don't assume they make as much money as you or have all of the things you might value. It's all a silly argument.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

I see it differently -- you found way to have other people provide your children a very good education and still allow you and your family to live the life you want to live.

+1 I agree. No other way to spin it.

And to expand on that you found way to have other people provide your children a very good education and still allow you and your family to live the life you want to live while simultaneously depriving truly needy children of the financial aid that could help their families escape the school-to-prison pipeline. But enjoy your vacation.

Exactly!!!!

Oh, poppycock. FA departments want a mix of middle- and low-income kids. PP isn't depriving anyone. If she didn't apply, that money would go to another middle class student.

massive rationalization. It's how one get's over a guilty conscience.

Not PP, but we get FA and feel 0% guilty about it. Grateful? Yes. Guilty? Hell no. Nobody's forcing the school to give us aid. They want my kid, they offered the aid, I accepted. Why would I feel guilty?

You are ridiculous.

Aren't we defensive...

No she isn't defensive. She is matter of fact. You on the other hand...jealous much?

Instead of beating up on the PP you should ask her how they managed to pull off getting FA so you can do the same. It's clear your jealously is killing you.

Unlike her, I'm not trying to pull anything off. FA is not some sort scam to "pull off" - it's there for people who are truly needy. 200K/yr is not truly needy. If you take it, it's not there for someone else. FA at its very best helps break the cycle of poverty in the inner city. At its worst, it is an upper/middle class subsidy that locks in existing socioeconomic structures and income inequality.

[Anonymous]

Just randomly checking out the private school forum. Our HHI is 95k. We have some equity in our home though (80-100k?). I assumed they would make us use that before getting FA which we aren't willing to do. Thoughts?

[Anonymous]

80% aid at a Big3 for the same income and we have similar equity.

[Anonymous]

The PP that's traveling to Disney, Caribbean, Asia, etc. while on FA, you really need a reality check.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Just randomly checking out the private school forum. Our HHI is 95k. We have some equity in our home though (80-100k?). I assumed they would make us use that before getting FA which we aren't willing to do. Thoughts?

Not at all. They let you have some equity. You don't need to spend down to qualify for FA.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Just randomly checking out the private school forum. Our HHI is 95k. We have some equity in our home though (80-100k?). I assumed they would make us use that before getting FA which we aren't willing to do. Thoughts?

Not at all. They let you have some equity. You don't need to spend down to qualify for FA.

Thanks to you and 10:39. I didn't realize this. We will keep this in mind should we decide to apply to private in the future.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:The PP that's traveling to Disney, Caribbean, Asia, etc. while on FA, you really need a reality check.

Oh please. Do you actually think these private schools want families that don't travel? Absolutely not. I'm my FA application I FULLY disclosed how much we spend annually on vacations. The reality is they are happy to provide FA for families who will fit it. I believe a PP called it "families that bridge the gap" between the poor and the extremely wealthy. No my DC won't vacation to the alps but DC also won't feel less than because she has to sit at home during spring break while her classmates when on exotic vacations. The schools are happy to have us. Our DC is bright, energetic, loves learning and isn't going to stick out as a poor disadvantaged kid you all seem to think are the only ones deserving of FA. I am quite sure they will also award those families FA. Yet they also see the value in awarding it to families like mine.

[Anonymous]

On*

[Anonymous]

The sticker price of schools/colleges keeps going up and up partly in order to fund ever-more-generous financial aid. Dual-earner incomes of typical senior faculty employees tend to be in a protected sweet spot for very substantial grant aid, with a sharp drop-off as incomes move up from there. What hasn't been mentioned is that admissions tend not to be fully need blind, so many parents who might get some aid don't apply for it in the hopes of improving admission odds. Then they experience the aggravation of knowing that other families at the school with similar incomes are paying much less.

It does seem sad that many posters apparently prefer to have the student body be less qualified and composed of rich kids with a handful of working class kids thrown in, but basically no one in between. Wouldn't such an approach remove many of the most outstanding scholars/athletes/artists/leaders?

[Anonymous]

This thread leaves a really bad taste in my mouth. A bunch of middle class people taking money from the super rich. Do you know that there are thousands of kids in DC who don't have enough to eat? That there are thousands of kids who are homeless or live in unsafe and unstable homes? Yet, this little circle jerk of entitled people who are too good for public school just leaves a nasty taste in my mouth.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The PP that's traveling to Disney, Caribbean, Asia, etc. while on FA, you really need a reality check.

Oh please. Do you actually think these private schools want families that don't travel? Absolutely not. I'm my FA application I FULLY disclosed how much we spend annually on vacations. The reality is they are happy to provide FA for families who will fit it.

"Families that will fit in? Oh man, that's a loaded term. Care to explain?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The PP that's traveling to Disney, Caribbean, Asia, etc. while on FA, you really need a reality check.

Oh please. Do you actually think these private schools want families that don't travel? Absolutely not. I'm my FA application I FULLY disclosed how much we spend annually on vacations. The reality is they are happy to provide FA for families who will fit it. I believe a PP called it "families that bridge the gap" between the poor and the extremely wealthy. No my DC won't vacation to the alps but DC also won't feel less than because she has to sit at home during spring break while her classmates when on exotic vacations. The schools are happy to have us. Our DC is bright, energetic, loves learning and isn't going to stick out as a poor disadvantaged kid you all seem to think are the only ones deserving of FA. I am quite sure they will also award those families FA. Yet they also see the value in awarding it to families like mine.

Schools really make admissions decisions based on whether families travel or not? Vomit.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:This thread leaves a really bad taste in my mouth. A bunch of middle class people taking money from the super rich. Do you know that there are thousands of kids in DC who don't have enough to eat? That there are thousands of kids who are homeless or live in unsafe and unstable homes? Yet, this little circle jerk of entitled people who are too good for public school just leaves a nasty taste in my mouth.

I get what your saying and and tend to agree with you. but do you really think those super rich people are going to give their money to the poor instead of it going to help a family with FA? Disconnect.