Yes I am serious. I actually just listened to the youtube comparison and I do not see it..or hear it. I am also a huge Tom Petty fan (not so much Sam Smith) but I do not get it. Oh well! |
Were their reactions based on the fact that they don't care for inappropriate dance moves, or based on the fact that Madonna is 56? |
I'm the one who posted the youtube comparison, but in some ways it's misleading to listen to it geared down and mashed up that way. The tempos of the two songs are different, but if you step back, the melody of the whole chorus is exactly the same. If you just think the first two lines of the "Stay with Me" chorus in your head, if you're a Tom Petty fan, you should hear the introductory guitar lick of "Won't Back Down" coming into your head, and then hear Tom singing, "Well, I won't back down, no I won't back down ...." It looks like you don't focus on melody. That's ok, we all listen to music differently. DW laughs at me because I don't listen to lyrics. I know every bass line, drum fill, and guitar solo from about 1957 to 1995, but I don't know any of the words at all. |
Don't you mean 1983???!!! |
This!! Mostly. For me, I see no difference in Miley or Beyonce, or Madonna performing inappropriate dance moves. My girls have accepted it with the younger artists. |
I like both of them, studied music, and don't hear it. I do hear similarities, particularly in the three-word refrain and the melody, but it doesn't strike me in any way as obvious plagiarism. There are quite a few differences between the two songs, and I'm inclined to think it was at most inadvertent influence rather than any overt copying. |
That's what they all agreed it was, unintentional copying. Still seems weird to give a song a Grammy for songwriting when just a couple weeks early the songwriter agreed to split royalties with a prior song's writer. |
Ha, my boys would have had a similar reaction I'm sure if they had watched it. I'm not sure what in the world Madonna is doing but when she dresses and tries to dance like a 20 something she winds up making herself look MUCH older than she really is. She's only in her 50's and she's even in decent shape but dancing like that makes her look stiff and unlimber. Elderly. Probably not the impression she is going for.. |
Yes, Norah Jones, Tracy Chapman, Christopher Cross, Adele (to some extent) All talented artists, but I agree with PP |
Embarrassing to whom? So, because Kanye is black, his antics makes you embarrassed as a black person? GTFOHWTBS. |
An old lady wouldn't be showing her ass, however. |
young thing - probably was born in the 90s . . . We're talking 80s, baby! neon, Esprit brand, high top sneakers, leg warmers, Hammer pants! ahhh - memories loved Madonna - listening to Material Girl right now! |
She's heading toward Kardashian Land. |
+5000! |
you mean an ASSet? |