I'm not pp, but I find her to be pretty clear. Why are you trying to chase people out of the schools just because they have money and want to help improve them? Do you want the schools to remain completely socioeconomically segregated? If so, how do you think that would benefit the poorer community? |
Who is trying to chase away whom? The only upset I've read about here is from people who don't appreciate parents or potential parents advocating for more healthy food and less T.V. zombie time. Is that what you mean? |
Yes, that is what I mean. OP seems to want to chase away the "gentrifiers." Why? |
| Dunno. Maybe she likes the Title 1 schools the way they are. |
Amen. |
That browbeating someone with "OMG the kids here have it so much worse than YOUR first world problems, you should just shut up" (which is not precisely what was said above, but I think amounts to the same thing) is basically going to drive many (not all, but many) new families away. In the suburbs if they don't want sugary yogurt for their kids, or TV, there is at least a chance they will taken seriously - they may not win, but they won't be guilted into shutting up. There are already enough factors pulling families to the suburbs, this could be the straw that breaks the camel's back for some. And I find the narrative of misguided, elitist, uncaring, liberal gentrifiers profoundly unhelpful, and unfair to people who are so different, in a good way, from the mass of upper SES parents. |
+1 I absolutely have to agree. That would be totally unacceptable. |
I know there have been some people browbeating about it, but I think the majority of posters are really just suggesting a little humility and to keep things in perspective. Principals, teachers, students and parents at high poverty schools have a lot on their plates. We have a really great principal who is very supportive of things like "no screen time" and "healthy food" but she has a huge job in front of her. It's nice to say that everything deserves some attention, but if I have to choose between my principal focusing on getting Chartwells to remove Trix yogurt from the menu and focusing on the many other issues the school faces (discipline system that needs to be consistently enforced, open houses staffed and outreach done, staffing issues in the school addressed, our playground equipment fixed so that kids can go down the slide safely, etc.), I'm going to focus on the bigger issues that are actually within the principal's control. Perspective, and some recognition that the thing you think is the biggest deal in the world is probably one of a huge list of things they need to address. |
I don't know anyone at my IB title one school who is fighting about trix yogurt etc. This is just a distraction (although I agree that I don't want junk food in school) the "entitled" parents want more music, gym etc for preschoolers, more fundraising, fighting down at city council for money for renovations etc...thats what the entitled parents are fighting for. So OP, you sound pissy cause maybe you were running the show at your underpeforming school, hell maybe you are the principal and now you are put on notice. Get over it or get a new job. You dont' have to thank these parents for doing YOUR job and making the school fucntion better for everyone but at a minimum get the eff out of the way. |
I'm not the OP, but a parent at our Title 1 DCPS is fighting over Trix yogurt. |
I am curious -- what is this parent doing/saying? |
Why can't that parent just tell their kid not to eat the trix yogurt? |
+1. We all know that food high in sugar results in hyper behavior that's hard to control. Why give it to kids if all it does is create distractions in the classroom 1/2 hour later? More importantly, school meals are the only meals many of these kids get. Shouldn't one of the highest priorities be making sure these kids get food that will actually help them to thrive, rather than just get them by until they get diabetes? |
|
OP - Why did you post on DCUM? You should know that it is not a helpful board.
Parent of kid who has no problem with "Between the Lions" or other educational videos. Parent of a kid that has been fed junk food once a week at some of the elite private school camps attended. Parent of a kid that looked forward to his Friday movie at his upper middle class afterschool care. |
|
Is OP posting to the wrong blog? DCUM is not famously full of Title 1 parents complaining about gentrifiers.
Second: OP please talk about what specifically the parents are doing that is annoying. Because I'm sure it is true and its sure to be funny. We are type B parents who moved from a more Title 1 EOTP school to a more economically advantaged school WOTP and I have noticed a difference but mostly the involvement manifests in a good way. Better options for aftercare enrichment, and no one is holding a gun to our head to force us to buy tickets to the fundraiser...the kind of fundraiser our original school never even tried to put together. It's like that earlier thread, you go from "what's a room parent?" to "OMG did you see the email the room parent sent, I think he/she is coming unraveled." We get so many emails from our new school/teachers/PTA/Funding Committee that we can't keep up. |