
I feel like you are missing the point. The point is that grading is lower at tjhsst compared to base schools and this is causing unnecessary stress. And stress is one of the primary drivers of cheating anywhere. |
DP. If kids are blaming their GPA for not getting into college, it's because they don't understand how college admissions work. TJ kids are compared to their peers at TJ applying to the same school, not the base school applicants. The schools TJ kids apply to typically know TJ and TJ provides a comprehensive explanation of it's grading scale along with the transcript. Private schools often don't weight GPA at all. Other districts weight differently. College admissions officers know how to account for this. What you're saying is simply an easy excuse for cheating. Changing it would inflate the GPAs but otherwise change nothing. |
They realize they are not as smart as they or their parents thought they were so they take a shortcut. They are in for bad news. |
|
Noone is excusing cheating. I am proposing a method to reduce the incentive for cheating. In theory, what you say about norming TK GPAs to base school GPAs should be true but there are just too cases where this doesn't seem true at the virginia state schools like UVA and VT. Kids with 1500 SAT scores (75th percentile at UVA) and extracurricular are getting rejected and the only thing that seems to be keeping them out are GPAs below 4.4 High SAT scores with middling GPAS get rejected from VT. I think there is a consensus that these kids would all have gotten much higher GPAs at their base school. I understand that UVA is a competitive school and noone is guaranteed to get in but the rejection rate from VT should be very low, and it isn't |
There are other factors besides academics. These schools also expect compelling essays and look at hooks like legacy and athletics. |
Virginia state schools do not look at legacy. This is a very specific problem at TJ with respect to virginia state schools. We're not talking about harvard or other ivy+, just UVA and VT. The tj students are being penalized by a focus on GPAs that are lower than they would be at the base school. |
If this were the problem then we wouldn't see so many kids at tj being rejected from uva but being accepted to more selective schools. Honestly just having a fair shot at uva and VT would alleviate a lot of stress at the school. This is one of the most cited reasons for kids not accepting their tj offer. |
UVA and VT should serve all parts of VA via geographic diversity. Not all kids should come from one school in NoVA.
Every kid who attends TJ knows they are competing for college seats against all of the other TJ kids. Kids who don’t have top stats should look at less popular options. |
But we also don’t know what kind of outside activities the non accepted kids were involved in. Maybe they exclusively did academic activities so the schools saw them as not having as much to offer the college community as a similar candidate who was more involved in activities such as sports, music, arts, theatre, etc. |
They don't though. The distribution of offers to these schools are overwhelmingly concentrated in NOVA. It's not even close. |
That's clearly not true. |
It's because university of so easy compared to TJ. I went to a top 3 public school and I studied max 1 hour a day. |
Everyone. I recently graduated and I can guarantee that everyone in my class, except the real geniuses, have cheated at least once. Everyone I talked to during my time at TJ cheated, and I know that to be 200+ people. Some are very minor through. |
You forgot those of us who just didn't mind the Bs. We didn't cheat either. -alumna |