I have identical twins and one qualified as a semifinalist and the other did not based on 1 question! They would have both qualified had we lived in just about any other state!! The non-qualifying kid is so upset and thinks everyone is talking about them at school. I told them that this is small beans - no one is going to care about this a year from now. Honestly, they won't even be caring about this over the holidays, when ED and EA decisions are released. |
My DS also just missed the cutoff with a 223 in VA. I was wondering about putting the PSAT score in parentheses after Commended in the honors section. There is just such a large gap between 210 and 224 and the score was in the top 1% of the state (just the selection index was not). He has a high SAT as well but I think the PSAT carries some weight in that you can only take it once. |
You're overthinking this. Colleges are not going to accept/deny based on this. |
Personally I would do that. I agree the spread is so wide it feels reasonable to indicate if you are on the far high end. |
Wow. I am amazed at the number of kids from TJ that made NMSF. My kid attends Maggie Walker in Richmond and only 18 made it there, which also seems like a large number for one high school, but nothing like TJ. Smart kids. |
Link to the TJHSST list? |
That is because TJ draws top students from all of Fairfax, Loudoun, Prince William, Arlington, and Falls Church—over 60 public high schools—so its pool of top students is far larger and more concentrated than a single-district school like Maggie Walker |
Why do people post stuff when they have no idea what they're talking about. MLW pulls kids from 14 school districts: https://mlwgs.com/admission/application-information/ |
Is there an Arlington list? |
https://patch.com/virginia/arlington-va/22-arlington-seniors-named-2026-national-merit-scholarship-semifinalists comeonnnnnnnn MoCo! |
Ha! And also yes. 😂 |
The College Board wants you to take the SAT multiple times, and has been making changes to encourage this. At maximum cynicism levels, I would wonder if they are willing to accept a bit more randomness in the mix on account of that. |
McLean/Great Falls? |