Again I’m not op. People can disagree with your opinion! I see you as someone that can’t fathom someone else thinks differently than you! |
| A guy I interned with used to jokingly call other attorneys "doctor" because the degree is "juris doctor". I imagine that would make OP's head explode. |
|
Then what do you think about teachers saying it is very possible that Dr. X has a degree that qualifies her to be called Dr., and just didn’t pay to update the system? |
JD here who HATES it when we get addressed as esquire. It makes me feel like landed gentry (which I sadly am not). |
another phd who doesn't call self Dr. I'm in an unregulated field but "doctors" who are ABD (which means didn't have the baIIs or ability to finish) or who got their doctorates online, don't count. I am, absolutely, an intellectual snob. |
This is peak DCUM |
I think that doesn’t make sense. Credentials matter and if you actually earned a doctorate, which requires significant effort and time you’d be so proud to make sure it was accurately reflected in all your credentials and professional associations. When I got my masters degree I immediately updated my profile and work info to note that significant accomplishment. I think there is high probability that the teacher is not being accurate and this discrepancy is concerning. Doesn’t pass sniff test to me. |
I mean, good for you. But, there are a lot of people who don’t base their self worth on what some archaic state data base says. Most parents, students and teachers don’t search that data base and say: wow! She’s an EdD. Now I’m really impressed. Especially since most people in this area don’t think an EdD is a “real” doctorate. I’m a lawyer. I was very impressed with myself when I passed the bar 20 years ago. But now it’s a means to an end— being allowed to do my job. My license has been sitting in the corner since I moved to full telework in 3/2020. Most people know I’m a Fed. Some know for what agency. I don’t think most know I’m an attorney. I love my job. But most people think it’s dry and boring. And I’m not allowed to discuss pieces of it anyway. All of which is to say, many grownups don’t run around telling anyone who will listen what their exact credentials are. |
|
Wow, two of my high school teachers with Ph.D.'s used the title "Dr." That would also be fine for any educationally relevant degree, such as D.Ed.
A rapper can call himself Dr. Dre or Grandmaster Flash, but not at a hospital or chess tournament. An "ABD" is an all-but-dissertation, i.e., dropout. It is not a degree, and clearly does not count. This would be annoying and pretentious at a post office job, but is clearly fraudulent in an educational setting. What if she asked to be called "Principal" or "Superintendant" or "Chancellor"? You can make the argument for tolerance by calling people by the name and title they prefer. In that case, some of her students might wish to be called "Dr.". |
Yes, I get that aspect. My diplomas are framed but now collecting dust. But if I required all my students to refer to my degree daily by using a title most other teachers and staff don’t require, then I’d expect consistency in the teacher having evidence of degree in a database and in professional communications. The inconsistency in insisting people call you by Dr., but then have no credentials listed anywhere is what doesn’t pass sniff test for me. If it’s so vital to be referenced by the title how come the proof of title has so many discrepancies in how it’s referenced or omitted in employment database? The incongruence is what’s a red flag to me. |
Right. But as the title says, “May”. OP has no actual evidence the teacher doesn’t have a degree that qualifies as Dr. Heck, I have a HS friend who graduated from med school, got her dream guy (who clerked for Thomas way back when, BTW) and dropped our of er intern year. That “Dr.” teaches biology at a private high school. |
OP: first: your login in mememememememe Second— a “red flag” ISN’T PROOF. And if you are going after someone’s professional reputation (and you don’t want to be sued), you need proof. Not a “red flag”. |
Why are you obsessed with thinking I’m the op? I’m not. I’m a parent that find this discrepancy odd. It is odd. Otherwise there wouldn’t be over 4k views on this. |
|
I have a masters but it’s not in the state database. My undergrad was enough for licensure and getting the transcripts again when I renewed my license was a pain. I sent them to HR immediately upon finishing for the salary change, but my license renewal wasn’t until 3 or 4 years later. Easier to just maintain status quo in the state database since adding the masters there was extra fees and paperwork with zero benefit to me.
I mean, who knows, maybe the teacher is full of it, but my guess would be a similar situation to my own. |