This doesn’t show it’s a failure and if in person is so great why are test scores and grades bad? |
But MCPS can't! Because it hasn't planned for it! Because it requires Board consultation! Because it didn't distribute Chromebooks before the storm! Because it didn't distribute educational packets before the storm! Because kids have IEPs! Because teachers haven't planned! News flash: many other counties can.
|
I prioritize GENUINE and EFFECTIVE instruction and learning. Which data thus far says happens best with in-person, face-to-face instruction. Synthetic, virtual “learning” is not real education. It’s a crude imitation that yields weak academic results at best, and many emotional and developmental harms at worst. |
That's impressive that ACPS not only did synchronous learning yesterday but also did food distribution for needy kids. Clearly their superintendent does more than make snow day videos. |
A few days or a week is different and we don’t have high quality in person so stop pretending. |
He’s failed our kids. |
|
There's a whole lot of nearby districts providing more education than MCPS...
Alexandria VA-Live virtual learning started Wednesday, continues Thursday DCPS-Asynchonous learning Wednesday, Thursday in-person with a two hour delay Anne Arundel-real-time virtual instruction starting Thursday and including Friday Baltimore City and Baltimore County-virtual starting Wednesday, automatic policy as they exceeded the three snow days built into their calendar. |
+1 Kudos to ACPS. MCPS central office should take a field trip there and learn from them. |
Virtual learning is no one's first choice, but let's not let the perfect be the enemy of the good. |
| This is not true virtual learning as it’s a fill in for snow days. |
It is an intervention to provide learning when in-person conditions do not allow, and it is indeed being provided virtually. The press releases from the various school districts (ACPS, Baltimore, NYC etc.) that have announced virtual learning have called it virtual learning. |
It depends how it is set up. If they have full class time and a regular schedule, yes, otherwise it’s a fancy term for filling in the snow day gap. |
From the Alexandria press release. I'm not an educator, but seems like virtual learning to me. "ACPS will shift to virtual learning Wednesday as schools remain closed Tomorrow (Wednesday) will be a virtual workday for students and teachers at Alexandria City Public Schools. ACPS facilities will remain closed for all activities for a third consecutive day due to inclement weather, Superintendent Melanie Kay-Wyatt announced this afternoon. Students, teachers and staff will instead move to synchronous virtual learning plans. “Class times will include synchronous instruction via Zoom, which means live virtual instruction with teachers, as well as independent work,” Kay-Wyatt wrote. “Teachers will also provide virtual office hours. Schools will communicate the daily bell schedule for the school day.” |
There is not a single piece of research, for MCPS or nationwide, that you can point to, that supports your opinion that no academic instruction is superior to virtual learning. Your "evidence" of virtual instruction failures, stated above, consists of a single newspaper article of complaining students who are mad about being asked to do work on a Jewish holiday and a single evaluation of MCPS summer school, which as mentioned above, is a narrow program covering a small number of students, along with being a program that has many design and implementation flaws. |
MCPS prioritized food distribution sites in their cleanup. Just because you didn’t hear about it, doesn’t mean it’s not happening. |