Is anti-Zionism anti-Semitism?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Yes because it opposes the existence of the only Jewish state on earth. If there were multiple Jewish majority countries then it probably wouldn’t be unless they only objected to Jewish majority countries existing

It's not as if Israel were created as some utopia on an uninhabited piece of new land. You don't get dibs on already occupied land because your god told you it's yours, many thousands of years ago. That is insanity, and exactly why Zionism is insanity.

Jews have lived in Israel since before Islam existed

And? So?

That doesn't mean it's a land just for Jews.

And it doesn't negate the fact that many (most) of Israel's immigrants are actually Europeans.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Yes because it opposes the existence of the only Jewish state on earth. If there were multiple Jewish majority countries then it probably wouldn’t be unless they only objected to Jewish majority countries existing

It's not as if Israel were created as some utopia on an uninhabited piece of new land. You don't get dibs on already occupied land because your god told you it's yours, many thousands of years ago. That is insanity, and exactly why Zionism is insanity.

Jews have lived in Israel since before Islam existed

So what? It doesn’t give them the right to violently take the land and establish an apartheid ethnostate.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Yes because it opposes the existence of the only Jewish state on earth. If there were multiple Jewish majority countries then it probably wouldn’t be unless they only objected to Jewish majority countries existing

It's not as if Israel were created as some utopia on an uninhabited piece of new land. You don't get dibs on already occupied land because your god told you it's yours, many thousands of years ago. That is insanity, and exactly why Zionism is insanity.

Jews have lived in Israel since before Islam existed

You know you have common ancestors? Just because some people converted to Islam, does that give them an inferior claim to the land?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Yes because it opposes the existence of the only Jewish state on earth. If there were multiple Jewish majority countries then it probably wouldn’t be unless they only objected to Jewish majority countries existing

It's not as if Israel were created as some utopia on an uninhabited piece of new land. You don't get dibs on already occupied land because your god told you it's yours, many thousands of years ago. That is insanity, and exactly why Zionism is insanity.

Jews have lived in Israel since before Islam existed

So what? It doesn’t give them the right to violently take the land and establish an apartheid ethnostate.

Well God is a real estate agent and he promised his super special white European chosen people that they could have the land 3,500 years ago. His commission was committing genocide on the indigenous though, which is no big deal since the Amalekites were also genocided including all babies and women.

[Anonymous]

I think the real consensus is that Israel is finally starting to lose the PR war. YES!

That, or DCUM is full of over-educated white liberals who cannot be relied on as a litmus test for this nation.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I think the real consensus is that Israel is finally starting to lose the PR war. YES!

That, or DCUM is full of over-educated white liberals who cannot be relied on as a litmus test for this nation.

Public opinion of Israel is in rapid decline - between the young and the old, and Democrats and Republicans. A slight MAJORITY now have a negative view of the country.

https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2025/04/08/how-americans-view-israel-and-the-israel-hamas-war-at-the-start-of-trumps-second-term/

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I think the real consensus is that Israel is finally starting to lose the PR war. YES!

That, or DCUM is full of over-educated white liberals who cannot be relied on as a litmus test for this nation.

Public opinion of Israel is in rapid decline - between the young and the old, and Democrats and Republicans. A slight MAJORITY now have a negative view of the country.

https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2025/04/08/how-americans-view-israel-and-the-israel-hamas-war-at-the-start-of-trumps-second-term/

Conducting a genocide on American tax dollars is bad PR. Who would have guessed?

[Anonymous]

[twitter]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Yes because it opposes the existence of the only Jewish state on earth. If there were multiple Jewish majority countries then it probably wouldn’t be unless they only objected to Jewish majority countries existing

It's not as if Israel were created as some utopia on an uninhabited piece of new land. You don't get dibs on already occupied land because your god told you it's yours, many thousands of years ago. That is insanity, and exactly why Zionism is insanity.

Jews have lived in Israel since before Islam existed

So what? It doesn’t give them the right to violently take the land and p an apartheid ethnostate.

how e it apartheid? Is Jerusalem off limits to all non Jews like Mecca is to non Muslims?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:[twitter]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Yes because it opposes the existence of the only Jewish state on earth. If there were multiple Jewish majority countries then it probably wouldn’t be unless they only objected to Jewish majority countries existing

It's not as if Israel were created as some utopia on an uninhabited piece of new land. You don't get dibs on already occupied land because your god told you it's yours, many thousands of years ago. That is insanity, and exactly why Zionism is insanity.

Jews have lived in Israel since before Islam existed

So what? It doesn’t give them the right to violently take the land and p an apartheid ethnostate.

how e it apartheid? Is Jerusalem off limits to all non Jews like Mecca is to non Muslims?

several Israeli, Palestinian, and international human rights organizations have characterized the situation as apartheid, including Yesh Din, B'Tselem, Human Rights Watch,and Amnesty International. This view has been supported by United Nations investigators, the African National Congress (ANC), human rights groups, and many prominent Israeli political and cultural figures. The International Court of Justice, former head of mossad just to name a few

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:[twitter]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Yes because it opposes the existence of the only Jewish state on earth. If there were multiple Jewish majority countries then it probably wouldn’t be unless they only objected to Jewish majority countries existing

It's not as if Israel were created as some utopia on an uninhabited piece of new land. You don't get dibs on already occupied land because your god told you it's yours, many thousands of years ago. That is insanity, and exactly why Zionism is insanity.

Jews have lived in Israel since before Islam existed

So what? It doesn’t give them the right to violently take the land and p an apartheid ethnostate.

how e it apartheid? Is Jerusalem off limits to all non Jews like Mecca is to non Muslims?

Google it. If you're at all aware of this conflict, you would be aware of the apartheid analogy. Troll.

[Anonymous]

All of my Jewish relatives are anti-zionism so I am going to say no on the question.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:[twitter]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Yes because it opposes the existence of the only Jewish state on earth. If there were multiple Jewish majority countries then it probably wouldn’t be unless they only objected to Jewish majority countries existing

It's not as if Israel were created as some utopia on an uninhabited piece of new land. You don't get dibs on already occupied land because your god told you it's yours, many thousands of years ago. That is insanity, and exactly why Zionism is insanity.

Jews have lived in Israel since before Islam existed

So what? It doesn’t give them the right to violently take the land and p an apartheid ethnostate.

how e it apartheid? Is Jerusalem off limits to all non Jews like Mecca is to non Muslims?

several Israeli, Palestinian, and international human rights organizations have characterized the situation as apartheid, including Yesh Din, B'Tselem, Human Rights Watch,and Amnesty International. This view has been supported by United Nations investigators, the African National Congress (ANC), human rights groups, and many prominent Israeli political and cultural figures. The International Court of Justice, former head of mossad just to name a few

all far left groups. Why don’t they do the same for Muslim countries? You have any idea what they do to Ahmadis in Pakistan?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:All of my Jewish relatives are anti-zionism so I am going to say no on the question.

Same here, and it seems to be much more common in the newer and younger generations as they see the atrocities and genocide being livestreamed to social media, especially tiktok.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:[twitter]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Yes because it opposes the existence of the only Jewish state on earth. If there were multiple Jewish majority countries then it probably wouldn’t be unless they only objected to Jewish majority countries existing

It's not as if Israel were created as some utopia on an uninhabited piece of new land. You don't get dibs on already occupied land because your god told you it's yours, many thousands of years ago. That is insanity, and exactly why Zionism is insanity.

Jews have lived in Israel since before Islam existed

So what? It doesn’t give them the right to violently take the land and p an apartheid ethnostate.

how e it apartheid? Is Jerusalem off limits to all non Jews like Mecca is to non Muslims?

several Israeli, Palestinian, and international human rights organizations have characterized the situation as apartheid, including Yesh Din, B'Tselem, Human Rights Watch,and Amnesty International. This view has been supported by United Nations investigators, the African National Congress (ANC), human rights groups, and many prominent Israeli political and cultural figures. The International Court of Justice, former head of mossad just to name a few

all far left groups. Why don’t they do the same for Muslim countries? You have any idea what they do to Ahmadis in Pakistan?

Bro, the whataboutism is just tired. For the last goddamned time …

We don’t fund those Muslim countries on the backs of U.S. taxpayers.

We don’t obstruct efforts to enforce international law on behalf of those countries.

Our members of Congress don’t make physical threats against ICC / ICJ judges and signatories on behalf of those countries.

Israel is the goddamned problem. You’re part of that same problem.

Demand new leads from whatever radical, extremist Zionist you worship in the twittersphere or whatever. Otherwise, STFU with the amateur hour distractions while thousands of innocent people are being slaughtered in your name. We’ve heard enough from you.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I believe it is. All Zionism says is Jews have a right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland. It's a central tenet of Judaism.

Anti-Zionism says they have no right to self-defense and denies the historical connection to Israel.

So when people say I'm not against Judaism, just Zionism...they make no sense. Zionism and Judaism are inseparable.

WWII has been over for 80 years and the Holocaust was one of the worst sins of mankind. The rest of the world bent over backwards to help Israel but Netanyahu's genocide is the same as Nazi Germany's Final solution and Netanyahu is right up there with Hitler, Stalin, Pol Pot, the ethnic cleansing in Yugoslavia.