So the Calm app is a religious app? Or the other meditations sites on the web are religious? My Peloton meditation classes are religious? You are on of the people who think Yoga is a religious practice, aren't you? There are tons of non-religious based meditation and yoga practices, sites, apps and the like out there. |
| Why are people opposed to teaching kids a method to calm their overstimulated bodies and minds down so that they can more effectively focus and learn academically while in school? |
Wait are you two not on the same side |
I am very liberal and totally against this, 100% should be only done with written consent /optional |
Because it’s not a method for that or particularly suited to children. It can have a religious element. It led my aunt into a cult which ruined her life. How bout I bring prayer beads and force all your kids to do it? Muslim ones, rosaries you name it. It does all that you enumerated above. Mediation is not always benign. Look at all the yogi scandals lol |
You choose those. They are not foisted on you before your frontal cortex is fully developed, nor are you peer pressured or mandated to do it. |
| Meditation isn’t religious, sorry nutjobs. |
Not sure. Teaching you to pay attention to your own breath so you can control yourself is not inherently "religious." It's these weird sorts of conservative beliefs that meant I didn't learn how to deal with or control my emotions until I was an adult. S |
| So breathing deeply is a problem for OP? Makes sense. |
| Quick, call Yougkin’s tipline. Also, give interviews to the NY Post and Daily Mail. |
Do some religions use meditation/mindful practices? Yes. Are all mindfulness activities religious? No. Do you see how this works? Some religions drink grape juice as part of their religious ceremonies - does that mean every time you drink grape juice it is religious? No. With your logic my preschooler should have written consent for snack time…. |
Aha! Thanks for letting us know who you are and your agenda! Now I can see there is no point arguing with stupid, |
This is not leading people into a cult: https://youtu.be/UEuFi9PxKuo |
| Meditation has been shown clinically to calm kids and help with focus. It can be completely non-religious. Good grief. |
| I think teachers use it like a “brain break.” When I worked in another state all classes did a “calm classroom” breathing exercise once a day. I purchased a copy for myself when I taught in VA and used it. It helped calm my class who I saw after recess a bit. Did every kid take it seriously enough? No. But I tried to get them all to and some seemed to enjoy it. It was like five minutes max. |