Every violent crime is a hate crime. |
|
No. There is a specific definition: In Montgomery County, a hate crime is a criminal act that is intended to damage property or to hurt or intimidate a person because of race, religion, ethnic background, sexual orientation, or disability. The State of Maryland also extends protections for hate crimes based on: gender, gender-related identity, color, or homelessness. |
This. |
No, not that. |
How exactly do you prove an ethnic “hate” crime when you can’t prove that the perp hates your ethnicity? But you know he did. |
Debate contests are once a month. |
... because he told you he hates your ethnicity. |
Yes, yes that. And I know why you don't like it, but it is what it is. |
Because if they punished things equally, blacks would be disproportionately suspended. |
^ This only creates division. EVERY crime is a hate crime. Raging maniacs don’t much care who their target happens to be. It’s not about you. |
Yes, this. |
Leaving aside the definition, which is clear that hate crimes are a specific type of act, it’s easy to say that all hate is the same until someone shoots up Your mosque or Your synagogue or Your church. If “your” group is the target, whatever that group may be, you don’t have the luxury of concluding that “hate is hate.” You need to have specific protections in place, and the specificity of the law is one such protection because it can potentially alert people to danger and help the community/law enforcement be aware of and also prepare for and address specific threats and acts. |
That’s just not the case. The DOJ has a clear reason why this distinction exists: Why have hate crime laws? “Hate crimes have a broader effect than most other kinds of crime. Hate crime victims include not only the crime’s immediate target but also others like them. Hate crimes affect families, communities, and at times, the entire nation.” https://www.justice.gov/hatecrimes/learn-about-hate-crimes In other words, bias-motivated crimes both a) harm a person directly AND b) intend to terrorize or intimidate a broader group beyond that person – hence making them a more serious offense. |
Yes. They should have been thrown out. Agree. |