Only called by unrelated nickname

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:At school she will be called Larla every year at the beginning until she gets her teacher to remember that she goes by GiGi.

That’s not a huge hardship. I’m an Elizabeth who goes by Beth. You tell them once and they get it.

Standard nickname it's easy. ..some thing unrelated is harder. Everyone is looking for the new kid.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:It's not a problem, but maybe you should just pick a different name other than Margaret if DH will be sad hearing it. Because your DD very well may wake up one day and say "I hate being called Summer. From now on, I will only respond to Margaret."

So maybe name your kid Maria or Megan or Marissa or Meredith or Matilda or Marigold or something else that starts with M.

+1

I would pick a variant or diminutive though.

Elizabeth: Isabel or Eliza
Mary: Maria or Mia
Nancy: Anna or Annabel

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Very upper class. Probably from the days when kids were almost always named after a living family member in the WASP world.

And anything that takes a one phrase explanation isn’t confusing! “Everyone calls me Pip”.

+1.

+2.

[Anonymous]

Make her middle name grandma's name. Simple.

[Anonymous]

Super common and southern and waspy. It’s fine.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Make her middle name grandma's name. Simple.

OP said no to that in her post.

[Anonymous]

I’ve Always gone by an unrelated nickname, OP. I’ve always loved it! It separates who knows you well and who doesn’t.

[Anonymous]

Old money rich people do it all the time.

[Anonymous]

One of my daughters goes by a sort-of unrelated nickname, and it's never been an issue. She's in her 20s right now and has never had problems. She just tells everyone, "I go by by Cricket."

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:It's not a problem, but maybe you should just pick a different name other than Margaret if DH will be sad hearing it. Because your DD very well may wake up one day and say "I hate being called Summer. From now on, I will only respond to Margaret."

So maybe name your kid Maria or Megan or Marissa or Meredith or Matilda or Marigold or something else that starts with M.

This is the correct answer. Ultimately it's your daughter's name and what she decides she wants to be called is the only vote that matters, so maybe go back to the drawing board.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Very upper class. Probably from the days when kids were almost always named after a living family member in the WASP world.

And anything that takes a one phrase explanation isn’t confusing! “Everyone calls me Pip”.

Not always upper class, but it's never been a problem for people I know.

Stephanie, called Pepper. Robert, called Pete. Etc. Most people never even knew their given names, & it's as easily corrected as "Call me Kat, not Kathy, please."

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:It's not a problem, but maybe you should just pick a different name other than Margaret if DH will be sad hearing it. Because your DD very well may wake up one day and say "I hate being called Summer. From now on, I will only respond to Margaret."

So maybe name your kid Maria or Megan or Marissa or Meredith or Matilda or Marigold or something else that starts with M.

Agreed. And I say this as someone who recently lost a parent, so I empathize with your husband, but perhaps some therapy is needed. I mean it's very possible your daughter could look like her grandmother, what is he going to do to avoid interacting with her because it might make him too sad? This is the sucky part of losing a parent before they get to meet your kids but he can't spend the rest of his life avoiding reminders of his mom because it might make him sad. It's not healthy for him, and it's not even healthy for your daughter.

Hey honey, your name Is Barbara, but you have to be called Katie because Barbara makes your dad sad because it was his mom's name, and no it doesn't matter if you prefer to be called Barbara at some point.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Make her middle name grandma's name. Simple.

OP said no to that in her post.

Well someone, either OP or her DH needs to be the adult and realize life is no longer all about them and their preferences.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Make her middle name grandma's name. Simple.

OP said no to that in her post.

Well someone, either OP or her DH needs to be the adult and realize life is no longer all about them and their preferences.

Ha ha! So it’s not the parents preference to name their child?! Whose is it, dear - yours?

The child can go by her nickname or formal name when she wants to. The family will probably always call her by her nickname.

[Anonymous]

Totally fine. My boss’s name is Elizabeth. She goes by Christy. It’s a non-issue.