4 year old asked how babies come out of tummies

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:The doctor takes/helps the baby out.

This is normally my first answer. Then I wait to see if the follow up "HOW?" gets asked. Then I'd say "through the vagina".

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:How was he born? Start with the story of his own birth.

But some version of, babies grow in their mommy's uterus. When the baby is ready, he comes out of the mommy's vagina. Sometimes a doctor has to help the baby come out.

I recommend the book, It's Not the Stork.

Co-sign. Start with this now--you'll be glad you did.

+2.

+3

[Anonymous]

This question is way preferable to “How does the baby get in there?”

Some version of: the mom pushes the baby out through her vagina or the doctor has to cut her tummy and lift the baby or.

[Anonymous]

why would you not answer with anything but the truth? you people are weird.

my DS asked when he was 5 and was relieved to know that the doctor did not have to cut the baby out in all cases.

[Anonymous]

This is also a good book as well
https://www.amazon.com/What-Makes-Baby-Cory-Silverberg/product-reviews/1609804856/ref=cm_cr_if?ie=UTF8&linkCode=sp1&showViewpoints=0&tag=amigi-20#R2MVH0AKWISDBX

[Anonymous]

“What Makes A Baby” is fantastic; without belaboring details, it keeps the doors open on lots of variations about how reproduction happens (and even gives a pretty great kid-level explanation of what DNA is and does).

It also answers this question. I just read it to 4 yo; highly recommend.

[Anonymous]

This is the easy part of the question.

The harder part is when they ask "how did the baby get in there?"

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:My 3 year old knows the doctor and the mommy decide whether the baby should come out the vagina or come out in surgery. It seems to satisfy her for now.

This is what we told my DD, although a little later than 3. There have been no follow up questions.

Originally she just knew that I had a c-section but not everyone does. Around age 5 she got very concerned about how babies were born before surgery was common, so I told her the vagina and that was it. We own a copy of It's Not the Stork that I plan to pull out soon.

[Anonymous]

I said the tummy muscles squeeze the baby out through a birth canal that has an opening between mom's legs. Then we looked at a rubber ducky and squeezed water out of it. My 4 year old was pretty happy with this explanation.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:How was he born? Start with the story of his own birth.

But some version of, babies grow in their mommy's uterus. When the baby is ready, he comes out of the mommy's vagina. Sometimes a doctor has to help the baby come out.

I recommend the book, It's Not the Stork.

Co-sign. Start with this now--you'll be glad you did.

+2.

+3

+4

[Anonymous]

Get a book to she can visualize what you are saying.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:This question is way preferable to “How does the baby get in there?”

Some version of: the mom pushes the baby out through her vagina or the doctor has to cut her tummy and lift the baby or.

Why is it preferable? You can't tell your kid what sex is?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:This question is way preferable to “How does the baby get in there?”

Some version of: the mom pushes the baby out through her vagina or the doctor has to cut her tummy and lift the baby or.

Why is it preferable? You can't tell your kid what sex is?

No, I'd rather not tell her the details yet. I found out about it at an early age from a relative who meant well but the idea of it caused me a lot of anxiety back then. My kid is a worrywart like I was, so I'd rather wait just a little longer. I'll look into the Stork book for sure though.

[Anonymous]

Mom pushes

[Anonymous]

I told my 3.5 year old that mom goes to the hospital and the doctor and nurses help get the baby out. That seemed to satisfy him. If pressed I would have said that I push the baby out through my vagina, which is a special opening between my legs. I wouldn’t have said anything about a c-section/surgery though, because my husband had surgery when my DS was 2.5, almost 3, and it was a huge source of stress for my kid seeing dad in the hospital and unable to move around.