SATC mistake? Can anyone elaborate?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Is Miranda's baby named Brady Brady?

Brady Hobbs. Steve's last name as their son's first name. Her last name.

She never changed her name.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Weren't Steve and Miranda split for a while after Brady was born? But I don't recall how that lined up with Aiden/Carry's timeline.

This. I believe they were separated for most of Brady's first year. Remember Miranda dated the hot doctor for the Knicks who lived in her building? He was at Brady's 1st bday party where Miranda finally confessed to Steve that she still had feelings for him. I THINK this was around the time that Carrie was dating Berger but I could be wrong.

So in one year and a couple months, Aiden dated, married, and had a baby, who is now old enough to hold his head up in a carrier? The timeline doesn't add up.

It certainly could've been longer than that. Miranda would've been pregnant for around 10 months, plus another year since Brady was 1. The audience doesn't know when Aiden began dating the person, and maybe the baby wasn't planned. Who the hell knows.

In reality, it was likely a hole in the plot. Plenty of things happened on that show that didn't add up.

A pregnancy is not that long.

[Anonymous]

Men do not gossip.

[Anonymous]

Miranda (and Steve) ruined SATC for me — so repulsive and annoying.

[Anonymous]

Thanks audience is to assume he is out of the bar deal and doesn't keep in touch with Steve.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Thanks audience is to assume he is out of the bar deal and doesn't keep in touch with Steve.

I would agree. In the second (horrible) movie, when he "happens" to run into her in Abu Dhabi, she's very surprised he has three boys. Clearly Steve and Aiden aren't planning play dates. I would imagine if they were in business together, their kids would occasionally play, and Miranda would know.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Thanks audience is to assume he is out of the bar deal and doesn't keep in touch with Steve.

I would agree. In the second (horrible) movie, when he "happens" to run into her in Abu Dhabi, she's very surprised he has three boys. Clearly Steve and Aiden aren't planning play dates. I would imagine if they were in business together, their kids would occasionally play, and Miranda would know.

This is an excellent point.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I've been rewatching SATC. I caught something...

So, Steve and Aiden open that bar together (Aiden an investor), Carrie and Aiden get back together, and Steve knocks up Miranda. Eventually Brady is born and Steve and Miranda marry. I'm assuming Steve (and Aiden?) still own the bar, but then, a couple years later, when Carrie is dating Berger, she runs into Aiden in the street and finds out he's not only married, but has a baby.

How did she not know?

Are we to assume Steve bought out Aiden and was no longer associated with the bar? I can't think of any other reason Steve wouldn't know about things happening in Aiden's life, and at least tell Miranda, who would tell Carrie. Right?

Pre social media craze. Now everyone stalks everyone.

[Anonymous]

Carrie ran into Aiden in early season 6 - first episode, I think. Miranda and Steve were not together again. Steve was dating Debbie.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Carrie ran into Aiden in early season 6 - first episode, I think. Miranda and Steve were not together again. Steve was dating Debbie.

Right. But they have Brady, so they see each other. Wouldn't you mention the fact that someone else you know is having a baby? Especially when you are an outlier in your circle, the only one WITH a baby?

I can't imagine not telling the father of my kids that was business partner was having a baby. If not only because "now we aren't alone!"

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Carrie ran into Aiden in early season 6 - first episode, I think. Miranda and Steve were not together again. Steve was dating Debbie.

Right. But they have Brady, so they see each other. Wouldn't you mention the fact that someone else you know is having a baby? Especially when you are an outlier in your circle, the only one WITH a baby?

I can't imagine not telling the father of my kids that was business partner was having a baby. If not only because "now we aren't alone!"

NP but I think this underscores that we were supposed to assume that Aidan and Steve were no longer partners. Remember all of that fuss about how Carrie destroyed him after the second breakup that we heard from the "face girl?" Maybe not surprising that he would want to pull out of a business he had with Steve and maybe leave the city.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Men do not gossip.

This explains a lot more than most women probably realize! DH is one of three boys. Sample phone conversation:

BIL: Wanted to let you know that Larla had the baby last night!
DH: Wow, that's great! Hey, what was up with that bogus call at the buzzer during the Spurs game last night? Can you believe it??? (Conversation continues enthusiastically dissecting the game. Despite new fatherhood, BlL clearly is aware of what went down at the game.)

15 minutes later, DH is off phone and tells me Larla had the baby.
Me: So, how are they? Everyone healthy? How much did it weigh? Do they have a name picked out?
DH: Uuhhh, I dunno. I guess everyone's fine.
Me: You didn't ask about any of it?
DH: We talked about the Spurs.

I am not even exaggerating for effect. Believe or not, DH and BIL are both incredibly devoted and involved fathers.