Ranking of students to recommend for HGC

[Anonymous]

At the parent meeting the organizers stated that the parent rec was a significant consideration and the tests are only one piece of admissions.

Let thee count the ways this statement spells conflict of interest. But, all me kids are gifted!!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:At the parent meeting the organizers stated that the parent rec was a significant consideration and the tests are only one piece of admissions.

You mean, the teacher's recommendation, right?

[Anonymous]

Teachers have the overview of everyone that has
applied. They see the student who is reading a high school physics book at school or whose questioning and understanding of material is at a higher level. Their rating is just one more data point for the committee. Unfortunately not enough slots for all the qualified kids.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:At the parent meeting the organizers stated that the parent rec was a significant consideration and the tests are only one piece of admissions.

You mean, the teacher's recommendation, right?

I heard they said parent's rec, not teacher's. I didn't go bc we have an older child already there but we also have a third grader so I heard this from other parents.

Fwiw, we spent less than 10 minutes filling out the rec and our child was accepted. I don't believe it has much weight despite what was said at mtg.

[Anonymous]

If MCPS valued the parent recommendations why do they ignore most parents and run a shop shrouded in secrecy with regards mutually sharing of information and partnerships with parents?

The parent recommendation for entrance to magnet programs is not worth the paper it's scribbled on!

[Anonymous]

Not sure why MCPS is downplaying the importance of the test. I find it hard to believe that the test doesn't have a cut off.

[Anonymous]

they are down playing the importance of the test because everyone know what test it is and kids all over MOCO are cramming for it now. results will be all skewed.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:The selection committee gets the same info for all kids no matter what school the kids go to.

1) Teacher's Recommendation

2) School's Ranking

3) HGC test scores

What are the tests? MSA?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The selection committee gets the same info for all kids no matter what school the kids go to.

1) Teacher's Recommendation

2) School's Ranking

3) HGC test scores

What are the tests? MSA?

No. It's a test specifically for admission to the program.

[Anonymous]

they are down playing the importance of the test because everyone know what test it is and kids all over MOCO are cramming for it now. results will be all skewed.

Excellent choice for the MCPS kids. Beats watching TV and may help with the horrendous performance in mathematics for some.

[Anonymous]

Are they using other tests results (Inview, Raven) to determine the ranking or just report cards?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Are they using other tests results (Inview, Raven) to determine the ranking or just report cards?

I assume it's neither but is instead of classroom observations.

[Anonymous]

they are down playing the importance of the test because everyone know what test it is and kids all over MOCO are cramming for it now. results will be all skewed.

Excellent. This is great news. Now if only MOCO students all over would cram for Algebra at the end of the year the results will be skewed towards success instead abysmal failure!