| Know someone got in Wharton with #4. Execution is what matters. But agree these are powerful ECs. |
These statements imply that people “get in” because of ECs when these kids were probably all-around exceptional. You have to have the full package. |
|
OP, your problem is with the idea that ECs are meant to "impress." They aren't supposed to be awards.
What impresses is how the kid thinks, the choices they make, their ability to reflect on what they've learned and what they want to learn. |
Actually I've heard of a team of boys that did a project related to testing for roofies and some related distribution method. Don't think it was jewelry though. College students have also invented BORGs to keep people from tampering with their drinks. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Borg_(drink)#:~:text=A%20borg%20(sometimes%20BORG%2C%20short,as%20jungle%20juice%20and%20punch. |
Actually I've heard of a team of boys that did a project related to testing for roofies and some related distribution method. Don't think it was jewelry though. College students have also invented BORGs to keep people from tampering with their drinks. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Borg_(drink) |
Really hope you're not trying to be funny. |
The parents did this, not the child. |
| Manually masturbate caged animals for artificial insemination. It worked for the person in Clerks. |
Is this real? I really hope not. There is no magic EC. Your kid should do what they love and go deep with it. Their passion and commitment will show if it's genuine. |
You are cynical. |
Where did Maya Penn go to college? I thought it would be Harvard, but I don't see any info online.... |
No. Serious. It was the nail polish dudes mentioned below. Used Google to look it back up. My point is these ECs are not as unique as you might think. And BORGs are a way of keeping people out of your drinks. "Several anti-roofie products have been developed by student teams to detect date rape drugs (such as Rohypnol, GHB, and ketamine) in drinks: Undercover Colors (Nail Polish/Sip Chip): Initially developed by four male students at North Carolina State University, this company created a nail polish that changes color when it comes into contact with contaminated drinks. The team later shifted focus to developing a "SipChip," a small, portable test kit designed to detect common date rape drugs. Smart Straws: Invented by high school students in Florida, these straws contain test strips that turn blue in the presence of drugs. They were designed for easy use in bars and nightclubs. NightCap: Developed by a team including a brother and sister, this is a scrunchie that covers a drink to prevent spiking, which was later expanded with a "SipChip" feature. Color-Changing Straws (MSU): Michigan State University graduate students created a straw that turns from yellow to red in the presence of drugs. Stir Stick (UBC): Researchers at the University of British Columbia developed a stir stick designed to detect drugs in beverages. These products have received both praise for their potential to increase safety and criticism for potentially shifting the responsibility of preventing sexual assault from the perpetrator to the victim." |
|
My kid has one very time consuming EC outside of their varsity sport and full time summer job. It is off the charts high EQ, absurdly analog, deeply genuine, and they got involved at age 11. It is not in any way academic or award winning.
I’d love to offer it as an example, but I’m afraid the group (which we love and respect) would be flooded with box-ticking people messing things up by joining/volunteering for the wrong reasons. I’m 100% certain it is why he had tremendous success with high school applications. The schools made it plain. It scales in responsibility with age, so he will just keep going with it. It’s something he discovered himself and had to beg us to allow him to get started. My point? I don’t think I/we/they could have gamed this. Listen to your kids and let them run with something nutty if they want it. It can’t hurt. And it might become the detail that makes them shine. I was worried about investing too much time in a quiet, non academic organization that has existed forever. I was wrong. No idea yet how it will pan out for college admissions. And I don’t care anymore. My kid found themself in service to others. The irony is that a few years back, I could easily have been the OP. Sometimes the kids are smarter than the parents. Thank goodness. |
Thanks for sharing your experience. I like the organic way your kid went about it. I'm confused though by "tremendous success with high school applications" versus "how it will pan out for college admissions." Is your kid in college now? |
Solid, meaningful, and suitable for high school students. |