Feedback from uptown all girls for K?
![[Post New]](/jforum/templates/default/images/icon_minipost_new.gif){kind=icon}
Anonymous
| Are you all at feeder preschools hearing decisive feedback? |
Anonymous
|
We got all good feedback from Chapin, Spence and Brearley. Chapin and Spence we got back in December and Brearley when we got back from winter break.
For us they were all strong in terms of feedback. Brearley has a new head of admissions and she is changing how Brearley accepts applicants. They are no longer telling families right after play groups that they want their daughter (like in years prior). They are taking a more holistic approach and looking at all the applicant pool (they are in committees now). So don’t expect to get a definitive answer from them until decision day. Although the feedback may get stronger as we get closer to decision day. We have a weekly meeting with our director and hoping to hear that we are still on track. We already sent out first choice letter and love letters. |
Anonymous
| Has anyone gotten more concrete feedback, positive or negative, at Brearley this cycle? Trying to decipher where we stand there |
Anonymous
| Seems the consensus is that no one is getting concrete feedback at B now |
Anonymous
| I don’t know what concrete means - we got very positive from B. Like the person a few posts up from this. It’s not concrete per se. maybe next week they will signal with “concrete” but I don’t know. I didn’t expect to get truly clear and decisive feedback but strong or weaker nudges from PSD. |
Anonymous
| Interesting. Anything “decisive” or nearly so from Chapin or Spence? |
Anonymous
We didn’t get decisive from Chapin or Spence, just very strong good feedback. We have a meeting with our director next week to see if the feedback is more decisive. Unsure if either school is giving full on “yes.” Or a strong inclination. Only because they are ISAAGNY schools and technically are not allowed to give a decision before Feb. 5th. I also think they are not feeling forced to give an answer now since Brearley has changed how they are doing things. |
Anonymous
Same as this! |
Anonymous
| FWIW, a Brearley board member did tell me that they are super yield sensitive and will significantly discount families that didn’t send them a first choice letter. |
Anonymous
| Lol now everyone will be jumping to send b a first choice letter |
Anonymous
Is this information for this year ? Our PSD specifically said Brearley doesn’t accept first choice letters this year. |
Anonymous
Sounds like the Brearley board member has old info., which I guess is not that surprising. |
Anonymous
Interesting…what does it mean if we already sent one to them? Is it not binding? |
Anonymous
| I mean none of these are *binding* binding, I think the main problem is that if you send a FCL and are admitted and don't end up attending that school they'll never talk to you again. |
Anonymous
| But you write a FCL to have an advantage, and now it seems we don’t? I’m wondering if we should write one somewhere else… |