Ha, yes. I'm one of those people who could pass for Jewish or Spanish or Italian or lighter skinned MENA (in reality none of those). I consider it my super power tbh - has come in handy travelling and in some neighbourhoods. My very celtic looking husband notices I get treated better and is a bit jealous |
|
No, because people are reasonable and when you tell them where you come from, they integrate it.
HOWEVER, I am the author of the thread about a staff member at my child's school who insists on assuming that every vaguely Asian-looking kid is Chinese. She doesn't even ask! She calls my daughter's friend "the Chinese girl", and has kept it up, asking my daughter whether they can talk to a Chinese exchange student under the assumption they share the same native language. She just doesn't seem to be all there, to be honest. After a year of this, the kids are getting irritated (none of them are of Chinese heritage). |
I get that too (not Chinese, but similar situation) - it is irritating when people insist that you are something or someone you are not. ie: start talking to you like you are another (person of that background that they know), for example. If I tell you I am not that person or that background, it means I'm actually not. |
That is deliberate and highly ignorant. I would be irritated too. I get mistaken for Hispanic all the time and unless someone kept insisting that I am I just brush it off. |
Do you mean ethnicity, OP?
And no, I'm not being pedantic. I'm wondering why OP mixed those 2 up. And yeah, I get upset if people guess that my nationality is any thing but American when any number of clues would help them figure it out. |
Since early childhood I was interested in other people’s religion (wasn’t raised religious) heritage, languages spoken in their family, ancestors country of origin, etc. I have no idea why. I am still genuinely curious, but not everyone wants to share that information, so I try not to ask, or make assumptions. I’m sure I e unintentionally offended people over the years and I cringe to think of it. I’m grateful to the people who have shared their backgrounds and stories with me.
Trying to learn without assuming. |
I am Senegalese and people are constantly assuming I'm from Guinea-Bissau. It is infuriating. |
People assume I’m Christian when I am not. They also often guess Irish. Nope, Jew of Ashkenazi / Eastern European extraction. It only bothered me when I was dating, because I wanted to date and marry within my religion. It was never a big deal though.
I have a friend who is blond and pasty white, with the most white bread name you can find, but Muslim. I have always wondered what kind of reactions he gets if people assume he’s Christian and if he corrects them. But I have never asked. And maybe he doesn’t correct them anyway, because in most contexts it wouldn’t matter. |
Many many times people think I am Spanish because I speak with an accent, even though I am born in Boston. It is not up to me to correct them. |
When I was in Ireland, people thought I was Irish until I started speaking. Clearly I am American, but I have Irish heritage. That was pretty cool though. NGL |
Replace "Jewish" with "White". Not great, eh? |
😂 And you just happened to give all of your children Hispanic names… |
Is your friend Eastern European from former Yugoslavia? |
I’m guessing you’re a redhead? My half Ashkenazi redheaded dd gets asked if she’s Irish. |