Best ice cream cake

post reply Forum Index » Food, Cooking, and Restaurants
[Post New]05/02/2023 15:07
quote
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Baskin Robbins. It’s an actual cake with ice cream. Some places like Carvel are really just ice cream in the shape of a cake with some crunchies.


+1, I find the ice cream "cakes" with no cake so disappointing.
[Post New]05/02/2023 17:30
quote
Anonymous
The Ben + Jerrys ones are great as are the Thomas sweet ones. I never had BR ones.
[Post New]05/02/2023 18:10
quote
Anonymous
We had our cake delivered so it was expensive but, very yummy

https://sarahshandmadeicecream.com/
[Post New]05/02/2023 18:14
quote
Anonymous
My DC likes to “customize” his ice cream cake on Cold Stone creamery website. You can pick ice cream flavors, crunchies, frosting etc. He looks forward to it every year
[Post New]05/02/2023 18:58
quote
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Baskin Robbins. It’s an actual cake with ice cream. Some places like Carvel are really just ice cream in the shape of a cake with some crunchies.


+1, I find the ice cream "cakes" with no cake so disappointing.


I find the ice cream cakes with frozen “cake” inedible.

Dairy Queen is the classic.
[Post New]05/02/2023 19:08
quote
Anonymous
Brusters in Gaithersburg...my birthday every year. It has a "gooey layer"
[Post New]05/02/2023 19:16
quote
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Baskin Robbins. It’s an actual cake with ice cream. Some places like Carvel are really just ice cream in the shape of a cake with some crunchies.


+1, I find the ice cream "cakes" with no cake so disappointing.


I find the ice cream cakes with frozen “cake” inedible.

Dairy Queen is the classic.


+1
[Post New]05/02/2023 19:21
quote
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Baskin Robbins. It’s an actual cake with ice cream. Some places like Carvel are really just ice cream in the shape of a cake with some crunchies.


+1, I find the ice cream "cakes" with no cake so disappointing.


I find the ice cream cakes with frozen “cake” inedible.

Dairy Queen is the classic.


I agree..who wants to eat frozen cake.
[Post New]05/02/2023 19:22
quote
Anonymous
We do Dairy Queen ice cream cakes. They are good and they have a wide selection (at least at the store where we buy them).
[Post New]05/02/2023 19:26
quote
Anonymous
Where are you located? Toby’s does a great job, and so does Jakes Ice Cream off Columbia pike. I’ve never tried cold stone, but I’ve heard good things.
[Post New]05/02/2023 19:27
quote
Anonymous
Brusters is the best.
[Post New]05/02/2023 20:05
quote
Anonymous
There is nothing better than Carvels.
[Post New]05/02/2023 20:13
quote
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:My DD has requested an ice cream cake for her birthday party. I'd like to try something better than a store bought Carvel cake but have no interest in making one. Any recommendation on the best store bought ice cream cake? I'm looking at Ben & Jerry's, Coldstone, Baskin Robbins and Thomas Sweet.


I don't think I can't stand for this disrespect of a Carvel cake. it's a classic


Agreed. I grew up in the same town as Tom Carvel and we had one of their flagship stores in our town. I went to school with his grand kids. This is a sacrilege! 😀
[Post New]05/02/2023 20:19
quote
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Baskin Robbins. It’s an actual cake with ice cream. Some places like Carvel are really just ice cream in the shape of a cake with some crunchies.


Which is exactly what an ice cream cake should be. I can’t stand actual cake in my ice cream cake: the cake is kind of gross when it’s all frozen. The point of an ice cream cake is that it is made out of ice cream.
[Post New]05/02/2023 20:19
quote
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:There is nothing better than Carvels.


Agree. They’re the best.
post reply Forum Index » Food, Cooking, and Restaurants
Message Quick Reply
Go to: 

Search   Recent Topics   Hottest Topics