+1. Let's shelve all these studies for 10 years and use the money to get more teachers in classrooms and reduce classroom sizes. ES class sizes at focus schools need to be cut in half. If that doesn't work at all, then they go back to doing studies. |
These proposals amount to platitudes. You know New Zealand is implementing a “plain language” in government? That might be a good idea here. Just clearly convey the exact things you want. |
Literally what does any of this mean / are there any actual actions, beyond a lot of packaged buzzwords? |
There is plenty of evidence nationally, and MCPS data is consistent with this though what they release is limited, that race by itself predicts outcomes (independent from class). When you break down the data by race and income, you see that Black children from high-income families do significantly worse than White children from high-income families. You insist that there's no proof, but you haven't even looked. |
Isn't the purpose of the audit to find the issues? The solutions need to be determined in collaboration with the community - that's a central aspect of anti-racist work. And that's what this audit is recommending. Not that I have any faith at all that MCPS will do this in any meaningful way. |
You're presuming they want to convey things. If they spell things out clearly, there might be public dissent. By phrasing things in incomprehensible ways, there is less public reaction, but when actual substantive policies are introduced, advocates can cite the vague word salad as having provided direction for their particular policy. |
| The far-right shills are on a real tear today, dredging up all these non-issues. |
Association isn’t causation. |
I mean there are a lot of studies showing the mechanism of how things work. Studies that show PRESCHOOL teachers look for bad behaviors in Black boys in ways they do not for White boys. This is not rocket science. To throw your hands up and say, "whelp, we can't do a double blind randomized trial, so let's just not address this" is a really disingenuous approach and I would argue you are intentionally upholding systematic racism. It is just too ridiculous, sorry. |
But just like we discussed in the Education forum, there are lots of potential reasons for this that do not necessarily mean racism. But that would involve some uncomfortable discussions and research. |
It's funny that you seem to think if it's racism, that would be a comfortable conversation, but if it's not, then it would be "uncomfortable". What "uncomfortable conversations" do you think this situation elicits? https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/oct/04/black-students-teachers-implicit-racial-bias-preschool-study |
Maybe but is it really MCPS's job to solve the problems with our society? Maybe they should focus more on educating kids. |
Maybe it's just me, but I don't think a goal of any school should be equalized outcomes. Equalized opportunities sure, but not outcomes. |
You didn't even bother to read the audit did you? It identified problems in MCPS, not society at large. |
And you didn't even bother to read my post did you? I was responding to a precious poster, not the audit. Take a minute and think before you post snide remarks. |