Is baking for a new guy a good or bad idea?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The only one that hasn’t liked it was playing me. Def ok after dating a few months.

He didn’t like it? What did he say to you?

He essentially behaved like a was nuts and wanting to marry him. Id made him muffins and left them after sleeping over, he’d gone to work. He’d already given me a key and we spent every night together switching apartments. He was a weirdo. Lovebomb type.

[Anonymous]

Depends...if there are nuts in the brownies, it is a dealbreaker.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:If you like baking I don't see the issue with an occasional surprise

+1. As long as he's showing he appreciates you too

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Depends...if there are nuts in the brownies, it is a dealbreaker.

Ha! I could never make love to a man who wants nutless brownies.

[Anonymous]

Is there a difference between baking and cooking for a man?

[Anonymous]

If you make me a tray of brownies you get unlimited oral pleasure on demand anytime. Cooking isn’t grandma-ISH or unsexy, if you have a skill show it off, that’s sexy.

(Yes that’s a pulp fiction reference)

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I would bake for myself and offer him one. I think baking “for him” or making a batch to give him is too early-1960s Seventeen.

What does 1960s-seventeen even mean?

Ask yourself this, would you want to be with a guy who judged you negatively for baking him brownies?

[Anonymous]

I was dating this guy and occasionally I’d see a pan of brownies or something in his kitchen. He never offered me any and I’d wonder who made them… lol

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I was dating this guy and occasionally I’d see a pan of brownies or something in his kitchen. He never offered me any and I’d wonder who made them… lol

Edibles.

[Anonymous]

I can't believe you needed to crowdsource this. Holy overthinking Batman.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Depends...if there are nuts in the brownies, it is a dealbreaker.

Ha! I could never make love to a man who wants nutless brownies.

See OP, this is a great step to weed out weirdos. Do you want a life time of arguing over nuts in your baked goods?????

Lol - agree with baking for your self and sharing some. I like to bake too but can’t have a whole pan of brownies sitting in my house so it’s a win win.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I’ve been dating a guy for 3 months. I like to bake and found out he likes brownies. Do guys like when you bake for them? I’ve read some books written for women saying not to, because that comes across as too “grandma” and unsexy.

What do you think?

If he is overweight/obese it is a good idea. You aren't dating those authors. Go for it!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I’ve been dating a guy for 3 months. I like to bake and found out he likes brownies. Do guys like when you bake for them? I’ve read some books written for women saying not to, because that comes across as too “grandma” and unsexy.

What do you think?

My wife of almost 24 years baked for me early on in our relationship - a cake that we brought to my birthday celebration with a bunch of friends. It sealed the deal for me.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I’ve been dating a guy for 3 months. I like to bake and found out he likes brownies. Do guys like when you bake for them? I’ve read some books written for women saying not to, because that comes across as too “grandma” and unsexy.

What do you think?

Relationship books are written to sell...not to live by. Everyone is different when it comes to what they like and what turns them off. You like to bake so make the damn brownies.

[Anonymous]

OP, you're taking advice from a book and now you're crowdsourcing whether or not to bake brownies for a man you've been dating for 3 months.

I'd hate to see what other advice you're getting...poor guy will never know the real you.