Close Contacts - How many end up testing positive?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:How are people not understanding the OP. It’s a simple question. Of all the close contacts identified in APS, how many go on to test positive for COVID? If a positive case is identified in a classroom and 20 kids identified as close contacts as a result. Those numbers show up on the dashboard. If a close contact then goes on to test positive it will show up as a positive case on the dashboard. BUT there is no data or tracking to show AS A PERCENTAGE how many close contacts go on to test positive.

For example, LA is implementing TTS based on the low transmission: https://ktla.com/news/local-news/l-a-county-announces-modified-quarantine-option-for-unvaccinated-students/


As of last week, among the almost 30,000 people that ended up quarantined, 63 tested positive.

“This amounts to what we call a secondary attack rate of 0.2%,” Ferrer said, calling the figure “extraordinarily low.”

PP here. The link is from September. I provided it just to illustrate what OP is asking.

[Anonymous]

I'm not sure I understand the question. Everyone who gets Covid gets it from being in close contact with a Covid positive person. That's how you get Covid.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I'm not sure I understand the question. Everyone who gets Covid gets it from being in close contact with a Covid positive person. That's how you get Covid.

OP is actually asking what percentage of kids who are forced into quarantine end up being positive. If a large percentage of the kids excluded from class end up as positives the process is necessary. If 99% of those quarantined don’t end up positive they are missing class for no reason.

[Anonymous]

The whole quarantining mess is going to go away on its own in January because there will be no more exclusions. At least that will something behind us.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I'm not sure I understand the question. Everyone who gets Covid gets it from being in close contact with a Covid positive person. That's how you get Covid.

OP is actually asking what percentage of kids who are forced into quarantine end up being positive. If a large percentage of the kids excluded from class end up as positives the process is necessary. If 99% of those quarantined don’t end up positive they are missing class for no reason.

Exactly. Schools that have kept track of this (shocking to think APS hasn’t) realize they are over-quarantining. It’s crazy low.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:The whole quarantining mess is going to go away on its own in January because there will be no more exclusions. At least that will something behind us.

Huh? Yes vaccinated are excluded for NOW. APS need to implement TTS. All signs are showing that everyone is up for grabs w omicron. We need TTS.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The whole quarantining mess is going to go away on its own in January because there will be no more exclusions. At least that will something behind us.

Huh? Yes vaccinated are excluded for NOW. APS need to implement TTS. All signs are showing that everyone is up for grabs w omicron. We need TTS.

Hoping Youngkin gets rid of quarantining close contacts, like in Europe and Florida and other parts of the US. Incredibly disruptive to prevent 0.2% of kids from getting a case after adults have been vaccinated for a year.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The whole quarantining mess is going to go away on its own in January because there will be no more exclusions. At least that will something behind us.

Huh? Yes vaccinated are excluded for NOW. APS need to implement TTS. All signs are showing that everyone is up for grabs w omicron. We need TTS.

Hoping Youngkin gets rid of quarantining close contacts, like in Europe and Florida and other parts of the US. Incredibly disruptive to prevent 0.2% of kids from getting a case after adults have been vaccinated for a year.

I mean I certainly hope he does even though I didn’t vote for him. There are a lot of ridiculous COVID policies that need to go. I’m doubtful this is something he can change.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The whole quarantining mess is going to go away on its own in January because there will be no more exclusions. At least that will something behind us.

Huh? Yes vaccinated are excluded for NOW. APS need to implement TTS. All signs are showing that everyone is up for grabs w omicron. We need TTS.

Hoping Youngkin gets rid of quarantining close contacts, like in Europe and Florida and other parts of the US. Incredibly disruptive to prevent 0.2% of kids from getting a case after adults have been vaccinated for a year.

I mean I certainly hope he does even though I didn’t vote for him. There are a lot of ridiculous COVID policies that need to go. I’m doubtful this is something he can change.

He absolutely can. Florida did it to align themselves with those barbaric Europeans doing the same thing.
https://www.nbcmiami.com/news/local/florida-students-exposed-to-covid-can-attend-school-if-asymptomatic-under-new-rule/2557461/

[Anonymous]

You don't have to quarantine if you're vaccinated and no symptoms.

The only people complaining about quarantines about anti vaxers. Get your kids vaxed!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:You don't have to quarantine if you're vaccinated and no symptoms.

The only people complaining about quarantines about anti vaxers. Get your kids vaxed!

And "no symptoms" - heaven forbid you have a coincidental case of the sniffles in winter time. Otherwise, you'll be locked out of school (just like last year).

Also, preschool kids can't get vaccinated and there are some other kids who can't because of medical or religious reasons.

Most importantly, the rate of vaccination nationwide for African Americans is the lowest of any racial demographic. The closed schoolers didn't give AF about locking disadvantaged minorities out of school last year and now, after substantial learning loss (see SOL scores for Title 1 Schools), they don't care about locking African American kids out of school again. Disgusting.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:You don't have to quarantine if you're vaccinated and no symptoms.

The only people complaining about quarantines about anti vaxers. Get your kids vaxed!

You do realize that the 5-11s are just now reaching the point of being "fully vaxed" - 2 weeks post vaccine #2. I know several kids who got quarantined for close contact just days prior to the 2 week mark. And of course none ended up testing positive. The reason that APS hasn't revealed how many close contact cases go on to test positive is because the number will be maddeningly small, showing that the policy is nonsensical. So you can count me as at least 1 vaxxer who complains about the quarantine rules.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:You don't have to quarantine if you're vaccinated and no symptoms.

The only people complaining about quarantines about anti vaxers. Get your kids vaxed!

You do realize that the 5-11s are just now reaching the point of being "fully vaxed" - 2 weeks post vaccine #2. I know several kids who got quarantined for close contact just days prior to the 2 week mark. And of course none ended up testing positive. The reason that APS hasn't revealed how many close contact cases go on to test positive is because the number will be maddeningly small, showing that the policy is nonsensical. So you can count me as at least 1 vaxxer who complains about the quarantine rules.

Yep. Another vaxxer (and boosted) with my kids vaxxed. Now that Omicron is here it’s just a matter of time before CDC pulls the recommendation that the vaxxed get to evade quarantine. Let’s get TTS in place now! And, yea, unbelievable incompetence that this isn’t being tracked.

[Anonymous]

Skip test to stay as we don't have the rapid tests. Let's just skip straight to the next step like Anne Arundel is doing, as well as many places in the US and Europe.

Get rid of the quarantines for close contacts. With less than 1% testing positive anyway, the cost to kids missing school FAR outweighs any benefit for a virus that will be here forever, for which vaccines are available and which kids are at less risk than the flu unvaccinated.

https://www.baltimoresun.com/education/ac-cn-covid-school-new-year-20211216-kxmpbvlf3veh3ocl7u7egk3u2m-story.html

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Skip test to stay as we don't have the rapid tests. Let's just skip straight to the next step like Anne Arundel is doing, as well as many places in the US and Europe.

Get rid of the quarantines for close contacts. With less than 1% testing positive anyway, the cost to kids missing school FAR outweighs any benefit for a virus that will be here forever, for which vaccines are available and which kids are at less risk than the flu unvaccinated.

https://www.baltimoresun.com/education/ac-cn-covid-school-new-year-20211216-kxmpbvlf3veh3ocl7u7egk3u2m-story.html

Yes agree. But I do think we’d have resources for TTS if we weren’t pissing them away with daily tests for vaccinated athletes!!