PP here. So we are from sort of the same era, and I was taught that the Civil War was fought to protect state's rights as well, with the nuance that the primary right the southern states were fighting for was to protect slavery and their slave-based economy. I compare that to what I've heard about the Deep South teaching that slavery had absolutely nothing to do with the war, that slaves were happy and loyal workers who wanted to "protect their masters," that slaves didn't want the war, etc. That sort of insane revisionist history I never heard about in Nova. FWIW, I moved out west for part of high school and they taught the same "states rights" primary narrative out there too (no lost cause stuff though). |
Virginia had de facto redlining, racial covenants, and housing segregation long after DC and MD. Virginia essentially forced its black residents to move to Maryland, as their kids could be safer and get a better education. The racial composition of NoVA prior to the 1970s was very intentional. |
NP. I appreciate your insightful comments, but just wanted to mention that the lost cause included talking about the conflict in terms of "states rights" in order to muddy the water. As PP states, the primary "states right" that was fought for was right to own slaves. Of course, no mention is ever made of the North's fight for states rights, for example not to have to send escaped slaves back to the South under the Fugitive Slave Act. The Confederacy didn't mind overriding those states' rights. |
You don’t think PG County in MD is dumpy? Argue by closer to DC than arlington, and I know many families who would never move there. |
It depends on one's point of reference, I suppose. |
+1 South Arlington had a large black population in the 70's - 80's. |
+1 |
I grew up in northern California in a pretty liberal area and came east to college. I dated a very sweet guy who had gone to HS in Alexandria (then, TC Williams; now, Alexandria City HS). Culturally and politically, his family and friends were pretty similar to my family and friends. Neither he nor any of his HS friends had a southern accent. When I visited Alexandria one summer, we went to dinner at the home of one of his HS teachers, who was Black and whose girlfriend was White. |
| I was taught a lot of states rights, yes slavery was bad but most slave owners took careful care of their slaves because they kept the plantations running, slaves were loyal to their owners, etc. stuff in the small town Midwest (like the upper/industrial/city Midwest, not the farm Midwest) in history class in the 90s. |
I went to high school in South Carolina and was taught state rights, but not the part about the slaves wanting to protect their masters |
I'm not sure this holds up as a historical matter. Racial covenants were declared unenforceable in 1948, but persisted in deeds well into the late 1960s before being declared illegal in the Fair Housing Act, which was federal legislation equally applicable to Maryland and Virginia. So not sure the big increase in Black residents in suburban Maryland was due to people moving from Virginia to Maryland so much as people moving from DC to Maryland and Black Americans generally feeling like Maryland, having not formally been part of the Confederacy, would be more hospitable. Relatedly, will echo those who note the teaching about slavery and the Civil War in NoVa public schools was slanted and biased towards an uncritical "states rights" perspective and lack of reckoning with the conditions under which slaves lived for way too long. Having said that, never heard the Civil War referred to as the "War of Northern Aggression" until classmates came back from schools like UVA and Duke and reported this was how some classmates from further south referred to the war (this is from the early 80s). |
Nope. Been in ALX since '71 qnd Del Ray was poor whites and low blue collar eveyone else. Del Ray really is a remarkable story but looking back it is a no brainer. You had under priced SFHs sitting on large lots (for a city) all walking distance to a metro and just across the river from DC. It's bonkers to think it was slummy for so long. |
Not to get us off topic, but like most of history, you can't whittle down complex historical issues to just two words, be it "state's rights" or "abolish slavery." Neither simplistic narrative is accurate. |
| Fairfax County was mostly farms at one time. Crazy. |
| There was no beltway, no 66, no dulles toll road, no metro, no malls. Prostitutes walked on 14th st, lots of boarded up store front, kids could drink at 18, Georgetown clubs were packed on weekends, you could get in line and go into the Whitehouse at Christmas time, you could go walk around inside the capitol blg.. low security compared to now. |