
Honest question, How attractive to college programs are kids who didnt make the grade, had diciplinary issues etc? Grad year seems pretty out there.
|
So the new info from this would be ECNL considering straight grad year for some age groups. No way anyone abuses that lol. |
Doesn't matter for boys. ECNL will be tier 3/4 in a few years. |
It would be for Junior/Senior year so the logic is by then one year of age difference shouldn’t matter because the two age groups are already merged together U19. |
Rubber baby buggy bumpers |
So, this is the sushi chef. |
You're assuming kids were held back or started late because of intelligence which we don't know to be true. But if it was Covid was 5 years ago so to say that kid hasn't not been thriving and has matured is pretty closed minded. We don't know every kids situation so stop assuming. |
I'm a teacher have seen lots of held back kids mature and turn it around by high school. |
This is the worst possible outcome for any Q4 2009. Lots of clubs do not have a U19 team. Which leaves these players out of luck and trying to find a new team their last year. |
If this is accurate intel — Where were these ECNL decision makers when the 9/1 date was selected instead of the historical 8/1, or allowing August (and July?) kids to flex and play with their enrolled grade. If these guys actually realize the quandary they are creating with GY implications for August players, they need to fix it before fall 2026 rollout. So dumb. |
That would only fix the August kid problem not the held back kid problem. I think GY is unfair but 8/1 wouldn’t fix much. |
I know one holdback he’s 11 and can’t read but he’s all about the soccer. He’s not getting an SAT score to get a scholarship so what the point in grad year?
Makes no sense to me. |
If true
Grad year is not the best idea, so at U16 the team could possible get blown up again to add July and August kids or whatever hold backs. Doesn’t sound like a great plan, with this kind of thinking ECNL may be in trouble in a few years. |
oh man, all you hillbillies worrying about hold backs. You think there are July and August 5 yo kindergartners at Sidwell Friends? |
I would say that’s between his club and family to decide to play ECNL a college recruitment platform or MLSN a pro pathway platform. Also if they are elite soccer players some D1 colleges don’t care if you can read or not unfortunately. |