Davidson: a bust?
![[Post New]](/jforum/templates/default/images/icon_minipost_new.gif){kind=icon}
Anonymous
| Just wanted to share some reflections on our recent visit to Davidson College. I toured with my daughter (junior at a very rigorous New England prep school), who’s a high-achiever academically and interested in double-majoring in math and history. Davidson has been on her list for a while due to its strong academic reputation and supportive community. Unfortunately, the visit left both of us feeling underwhelmed. The campus felt underwhelming and outdated, and the surrounding town lacked the vibrancy and intellectual energy she’s looking for. While Davidson may suit students seeking a quiet, sports-knit community, it just didn’t click for us. We were also concerned by the prominence of Patterson Court and Greek life, which seemed at odds with the academic culture she’s hoping for. Online several students mentioned difficulty getting into upper-level courses, especially in math. Ultimately, the outcomes didn’t seem to justify the cost compared to strong in-state options we have in Maryland. Any families have a similar experience? We've only heard the "pros" on this site and think we need to open this discourse! |
Anonymous
| Why does she just need to limit herself to in state schools. If you can afford a NE prep school, there are lots of options. |
Anonymous
| The surrounding town lacked “intellectual energy”? What? |
Anonymous
That’s a cute way to say dumb. |
Anonymous
| I apparently also lack “intellectual energy” because I’m not sure what discourse needs to be opened. Davidson is not the college for your daughter for the reasons you’ve stated. For other students, it is (or will be) a perfect fit. Your observations may or may not be helpful to others considering applying. |
Anonymous
| Just to share we had a similar experience at Davidson last year. Everyone was very nice, but the tour guide gave very generic answers to most questions including why he chose Davidson. I know many people love the school, but the tour was underwhelming. |
Anonymous
| Your daughter will struggle in life so hope you have a lot of money. |
Anonymous
I caution folks not to draw too many conclusions from student-led tours. |
Anonymous
| Maybe High Point could offer the “intellectual energy” you desire. Lots of entitled rich kids there. |
Anonymous
| A friend whose family visited recently also wasn’t into it. I’m glad to have these impressions to avoid the hassle of driving down and touring. I have heard some good things but it’s not top of the list. |
Anonymous
| Congratulations, OP, this is exactly what touring colleges is all about -- to help you and your kid narrow down what you like and don't like. You have figured something out, though I'm not sure it was necessary to share with the group. |
Anonymous
| Valuable post OP for others who are considering it - always good to get another perspective. Not sure about the intellectual energy comment. Does Ithaca have it? (I think not?)maybe Ann Arbor? Hamilton for sure doesn’t? Canbridge does. |
Anonymous
Same. The notable lack of vibrancy was also concerning. |
Anonymous
| I understand what you mean by the intellectual energy part. It’s a beautiful little campus, but nearby Lake Norman is lined with McMansions of NASCAR celebrities and a Trump golf course. That’s the vibe in the area. |
Anonymous
|
I appreciate the reflections, OP. I’ve only heard the really positive takes on Davidson, so it’s helpful to hear the flip side.
I assume with a desire for a really strong academic reputation, a supportive community, less of a focus on the greek community, and with a desire for a double major in history and math, she’s looking at William & Mary and Carleton? If not, would strongly recommend both schools. |