I agree. My son did not apply to UK schools because of the assault of freedom of speech and cuts to research. This was not even on his mind. He applied because he wants to have an international career. It is that simple. |
Not Glasgow? The home of the Scottish Enlightenment, Adam Smith, David Hume, et al? |
Not sure what the issue is here . PP specifically mentioned Glasgow alongside Edinburgh and St Andrews… |
Glasgow, more recently home of trash collection strikes, giant rats, museums and parks that are not maintained, ENORMOUS crime rates. |
Glasgow is a fine university, but its “campus” is unappealing to many. Many would choose Edinburgh instead, purely on the university environs. |
Glasgow has some issues for sure. This drives US kids to focus applications on Edinburgh and St Andrews when looking at Scotland |
Glasgow has always had issues, it is the ghetto of Scotland. What drives kids in the US to apply to St. Andrews & Edinburgh is largely down to the associated prestige and rankings. |
The college admission process in this country is broken. The definition of merit has been hijacked by wealthy elitists who will do and say anything to get ahead. If an overseas education can offer a similar or better education I am all for it. |
In the US, college admissions has never had a close correlation with any definition of merit. The admissions game definitely has changed over the past 100 years or so, but in any given year it always has been a game. My spouse has trouble grasping this, because in his part of Europe there is a national academic test for college admissions. One's college options there are primarily driven by the results from that one test. |
I dont think the grades/tests only requirements of English universities is the best way, or the rest of the world single admissions testing or the US more holistic scheme is the best way.
But there should be some acknowledgment of qualitative variables. Clearly some universities do a better job than others. |
+1. If this was the case in the US, admission rates to Ivies would increase by 500 to 1000 bps….it is that simple. |
Is he German? |
Its not grades / tests only for UK universities. There are detailed letters of recommendation required and for now, a personal statement. In highly competitive STEM courses at somewhere like Bath University, they say they only read the PS when they need to use it as a tie breaker between applicants. Other universities lean heavily into it and will discuss the content in interview, or the admissions officer may well be a member of the teaching dept, say for History at York. Their academic interests aligning with those in the PS, or the analysis shown in the PS resonating will more likely end in an offer. And a Personal Statement is not a list of activities or boasting about achievements, it is meant to be a place where the appliant talks about the insights they gained from a specific experience, specific books read, etc etc My kids variously played musical instruments to a high level, gaining distinction from awarding music bodies (in the UK), they learned a host of languages (Arabic, Chinese, Italian, French) and none of these things made it into their PS because they were not subject relevant. And they still got offers from everywhere they applied to. |
Curious how you left out the research cuts, which do affect most Americans. |
For which STEM fields is Edinburgh better? What about physics? |