Are all Dutch ovens the same?
![[Post New]](/jforum/templates/default/images/icon_minipost_new.gif){kind=icon}
Anonymous
|
Apparently Alexa knows I’ve been looking at Dutch ovens and on prime day much of the le
Cruset line was on sale. But I have found cheaper Dutch ovens at World Market, Tjmaxx, and target. I also saw another brand ?heyday? Which has these pretty matte soft colors and also cheaper. My main question is are all Dutch ovens the same no matter the brand or should I be really investing in one? Final note- I’m on the hook for thanksgiving and I’d like to treat my mom to braised short ribs. |
Anonymous
| I have a le crueset and a lodge. They are equally good. |
Anonymous
| I had a Martha Stewart one off of my wedding registry and it was later recalled for the inside chipping off. I've since gotten a Le Creuset. Both worked pretty much the same, but I'm not worried about my Le Creuset having the same issues as the MS one did. |
Anonymous
| My Martha Stewart brand Dutch oven scratched and rusted along the edge after about 3 years. My Le Creuset lasted 10, and that was with me not knowing how to properly care for it for a few years. I’m sure it could have lasted longer! |
Anonymous
| Lodge and Staub are fine. |
Anonymous
|
Can’t speak to other brands, but my Le Creuset is still in perfect shape after 20+ years.
I’m a total cheapskate, but it was worth every penny. |
Anonymous
| Lodge always gets great ratings (as a more affordable option) from various sources (consumer reports, wire cutter, etc). |
Anonymous
| We have had le creuset for decades and still great. |
Anonymous
| You can definitely find Le Creuset at HomeGoods/Marshall’s/TJ Maxx. They also have an outlet store in Leesburg. Here’s the Wirecutter article on the best ones: https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/best-dutch-oven/ |
Anonymous
| I would only buy Lodge, Le Creuset, or Staub. I like the aesthetics of Le Creuset or Staub better but they will all work the same and will last forever. |
Anonymous
| Got ours at Aldi almost a decade ago and it’s in perfect condition. And I don’t have a heart attack when someone uses metal to scrape the bits off the bottom. Worst that happens is I drop another $40 on the next one. |
Anonymous
| I love my Le Creuset collection. Every piece I have is still in mint condition after several years, and I use them frequently. |
Anonymous
|
My parents are still using the Le Creuset that they got as a wedding present, and they celebrated their 50th this year.
We got ours 20 years ago and there is not a chip or scratch on it. |
Anonymous
We've thrown away the couple of pieces that we got for our wedding. The chipped and rusted under the chip. Our Staub dutch oven is still great though |
Anonymous
| We have Staub and Le Cruiset. Love both. |