I'm Jewish and think the name Eidel is ugly - both written and said out loud. By now I hope the baby is out and you've picked a better name. |
Given that this thread is from 2019, I’m guessing little Eidel is in kindergarten by now. |
Jewish and never heard of this name before. I think it's funny/bizarre that cohen had become a popular first first name amongst non jews |
I think that naming a Christian child, or a culturally Christian nonreligious child, a Biblical name like Daniel, or Rebecca is totally fine.
I think naming a child a name that is strongly associated with one culture that you are not a part of is weird. I happen to love the Czech name Zdenek, and the Sanskrit name Anjali, and Taavi which is the Estonian and Finnish version of David. I think it would be weird for me to use any of those names on my kid with Irish, English, and Dutch ancestry. I think a modern Hebrew name, or a Yiddish name on a kid who doesn't have have a connection to Judaism or Israel is also weird. |
I am half Ashkenazi Jewish and half Irish Catholic, raised Catholic. My DH is WASP and our last name reflects that. So my DC has an Old Testament Hebrew-derived first name and a traditionally Irish American middle name after a relative. DC has a very WASPy look, but it was important to me to honor my heritage. |
Interesting, I'm a Russian speaker but Christian and I've always thought of Lev as just a Russian name. |
I know one Adam who said that he thinks that his name is old fashioned |
Nope, I actually think Soledad O’Brien. But I didn’t know there was a prison named Soledad, so there’s that. |
So no more kids named Sarah, Matthew or Mary? |
Those are English names |
Lol think the poster is referring to biblical names... but Matthew and Mary are new testament |
I know this is an old thread, but everyone just do whatever you want to do |
Same reason so many non-Irish families have kids named Jayden, Braden, and Aiden. As a Jew, my first instinct is that I don't like this - but maybe it'll help people dislike Jews less, if you start using our olde timey names for your kin! Go for it. If you're thinking you want a kid named Shmuel, you're probably not the only one. Soon there'll be a whole preschool class of em. |
I think only religious Christians are named Jedidiah. I certainly assume someone comes from a Christian family when I hear that name. I would never assume they were Jewish. (I'm Jewish.) |
Sorry I responded before realizing that young Eidel Jones is now in law school! |