|
Horticulture is the new thing.
General rule of thumb: the best "different" ECS are activities that are unusual for kids (and are usually not career related). |
|
your kid could have been rejected for a lot of reasons though. examples might be: 1. stronger applicants from your own high school (whether hooked or not) - always competing against your peers 2. something in LOR or kid didn't max out rigor (compared to what other successful candidates did from your high school in the past) 3. tone of essays implied outside help 4. not enough alignment with mission or values of school 5. maybe your kid applied TO, and from your high school kids that are TO with that GPA tend not be strong performers (yes, they use the historical data like that) Given V only has 3 things that are very important in CDS (rigor of secondary school record, GPA, and class rank), maybe it was one of those things? Just my 2 cents. |
Whoops. Screwed up my reply, which follows: My kid earned his PPL at 17 and still got rejected (not even deferred!) from Villanova ED1 last year. Tons of other ECs, 450+ service hours, and surrounded by green checkmarks on Naviance. So don't all rush out there to start taking flying lessons. |
And Villanova is looking for: students who are “intellectually inspired, morally grounded, and globally minded” and those who have the capacity to be change-makers, chance-takers, and difference-makers. Some of that would have to be evidenced in essays/ECs/LOR. Again just a parent here - who is thinking about going into college counseling and advising others. Hope this is helpful and not salt in the wound. |
It is helpful and not salt in the wound We all moved on a long time ago and my son is happy at his ED2 school. I only mentioned his PPL story to illustrate that an "interesting" (for lack of a better word) EC is not a silver bullet when it comes to admissions. (Two students from his class *were* accepted ED1, both of whom were legacy. He had max rigor, more APs, higher SATs [though at least one of those kids went TO], higher GPA ... sometimes it just is what it is.)
|
This would be true everywhere though. Not just for the PP and Villanova. |
Sounds like a quota from your school ? |
Or skeet shooting? Fly-fishing Think many ivies (at least Cornell and Dartmouth) have clubs for both. |
| The bar to private pilot is having money to spend. |
Be gentle - it’s probably the daughter of the poster. She “saw the application of an Asian female” LOL! Congrats mom! |
Or Admityogi (if so, I saw this applicant too)…. |
#2 is the most common reason a kid "surrounded by green checks" is rejected. |
This describes the vast majority of DD's engineering friends at her ivy. 6 of 8 came in with at least one post BC-calculus course and a slew of other stem APs to boot. They all have this "other"factor that they have done for years that seems to really matter to them. |
| bump...for those looking at how a narrative develops naturally. |