Well both of you are wrong. It's parents and family, not the curriculum, that is the cause of these issues. At least in regards to FCPS, there is already a process to identify and nurture advanced academics in every school, just about. People have been trying to solve this equity problem for decades but always fail to realize they are always treating symptoms. |
Some posters are very committed to the false narrative about decline in standards. They prefer the rigged system where only wealthy students whose parents could afford to buy the test had a shot at admission. |
And what, precisely, do you believe the "disease" is? |
96% had finished more than Algebra 1 before the class of 2025. That number is up to 30%+. TJ has had to implement remedial math instruction since the class of 2025 began. There is no false narrative. These are facts. |
Some families can’t, won’t, or don’t know how to provide a nurturing environment with a focus on academics. The are many reasons for these circumstances, but none of them are related to equitable instruction or the school district not doing enough to close the gap. |
Are you suggesting that students who come from these families are now being admitted to TJ in significant quantities? And as a follow-up, what do you suggest that students do who aren't lucky enough to be born into families that do provide these environments? Wouldn't it be more impressive to you to see a student succeed in the context of their environment without such supports, even if the level that they reached were slightly behind what a fully supported (and in many cases, micromanaged) student attained? For many of these families, their inability to provide these supports comes not from a lack of focus on academics, but from a significant need to focus on other things (food, shelter, safety). If you truly want to solve these issues, you need to vote for people who will swim against the consistent stream of wealth being transferred upward in society. |
Even before that, as the infamous math emails show. (That was due to learning loss from the pandemic (which the faculty called "attitude") though so maybe you think it's okay?) |
People spout this number as though it's supposed to mean something. What do you think it means, other than the fact that FCPS is now opening TJ's doors to more students who are merely "advanced" in math rather than "super-advanced"? |
People spout this number as though it's supposed to mean something. What do you think it means, other than the fact that FCPS is now opening TJ's doors to more students who are merely "advanced" in math rather than "super-advanced"? |
1) My comment was about ground up approach to equity in education, K-8, that may lead to better TJ outcomes for URM, but even more for equity in schools as a whole. This is a not a school issue. 2) Don't have an answer. Can't get new families. As you said, it's bad luck. 3) I disagree with your assertion that they are just slightly behind and so it's not as expected. Tests tend to tell the story a little clearer. 4) While people have free will, choice, and freedom, you will not solve those issues and I don't support taxing people to keep trying to find out this simple truth. |
The emails don't indicate remedial math instruction |
The issue is that it's closing its doors to many - if not most - students with geometry or higher in 8th grade (super advanced according to you) |
They indicated the need for it although it was not implemented. |
The TJ door is closed to the majority of applicants. There are more applicants than seats... |
I appreciate the reasonable response. I disagree that we should simply throw our hands up and tell children who aren't born into a specific circumstance that they're just plain out of luck when it comes to advanced academic opportunities. The reality is that they are slightly behind. It's a relatively small number of kids who are now being admitted who are just one year of math less advanced. I do think that your assertion in 4) is worth digging into somewhat. Is it your contention that the delta in prioritization of academics between Asian families and, say, Black families is so high as to justify a world where more Asian students were admitted to TJ in the Class of 2024 than there had been Black students admitted in its 35-year history to that point? I would imagine that you know as well as I do that poverty significantly limits free will, choice, and freedom. We live in a society that tells a burger flipper that if they want a living wage, they shouldn't be flipping burgers - which tacitly acknowledges that we need burger flippers but that those people should live in poverty. |